Quote:
The Patriots are coming off a bye, players rested and most if not all coming back from injury. Jets just flew back from Oakland...The Dolphins were also coming off a bye
my guess is that you're overrating the effect the byes have, though I'd actually be interested to learn exactly how many points a line will actually move b/c of one.
I think when the Jets come to Foxboro, they will be 8 or 9 point dogs, or something like that. something along the lines of the spread difference indicated by Miami @ NYJ vs Miami @ Foxboro
Quote:
without their best run stopper and arguably best defender and dealing with injuries elsewhere.
Pats have plenty of injuries as well. is Jenkins more valuable to the Jets than Matt Light is to the Pats? I mean, a great LT is critical for a team that throws as much as the Pats, and Jenkins is very valuable to the Jets D. though, Vollmer has filled in well so far for Light and the Jets D still overwhelmed the Dolphins wo Jenkins.
other parts of the offense missing were Sammy Morris, Fred Talyor, and Julian Edelman who while being a rookie has been our 3rd WR. so it's not like we are going 100% here.
more importantly, the injuries of both teams reflect their current realities - wondering what it could be if different players were around might be interesting to discuss but ultimately meaningless.
Quote:
I just think using betting line as a 'more meaningful metric' isn't right
using betting lines (esp closing betting lines) to create 'power rankings' is probably the best method there is. go ask anyone in Sports Betting what % of bettors can beat NFL closing lines, and they'll tell you: almost no one. which means they are very accurate at judging team strength each week, certainly way better than whatever Peter King or Dan Banks or me or you or whoever happens to think.
Quote:
and when it comes to defense and the Pats are higher saying they are higher then the Jets. That should be assumed, the Pats had a BYE week and the Jets didn't
this is why I used per game point differential along with the totals. regarding whose defense is better, eh, different metrics say different things. it's close. the Jets have played a bit better to this point, but going forward I think it will be close to a wash