A lot of these decisions overlap. Maybe we should try a week with combining these threads, and then maybe have a weekly general thread to discuss injuries and such. If enough people disagree, maybe we'll split them.

Suggested house rules:

1. Always post match ups
2. Always specify scoring
3. Always remove obvious starts (e.g. Peterson vs. Detroit) to make your list more readable
4. Always remove player ambiguity (e.g. Mike Williams)
5. If you're going to ask for help on filling N spots, reply to the posts of at least N people, even if you're giving a second or third opinion.

Ugh, I have QB issues. I dropped Kolb for Vick last week but somebody picked him up and now I'm left with Matt Turdbeck. Need best option between this group:

6/-2, no neg points for fumbles.

Matt Hasselbeck vs SD

Free agents:
Shaun Hill @ MIN
Sanchize @ MIA
Josh Freeman vs PIT

Chris Ivory add add add. Assuming Bush is out for a while.

Hmm, wait is Ivory healthy? Looks like no. Add anyways.

Umm, Hill? Prob get killed before game is over though. Hasselbeck is the safe option. Safe to get you like 10 points at most.

Which TEs to add for the rest of the season:

Aaron Hernandez
Dustin Keller
Tony Moeaki

separate threads.

I'd take Keller. Hernandez looked a bit like Dallas Clark last week but color me skeptical of rookie tight ends. Edelman will get healthy and take more of his snaps in weeks to come if I had to guess, Hernandez won't catch more than Welker, Moss, Edelman, Tate, or Faulk so how many catches does that leave? And Gronkowski is still getting most of the snaps at tight end. Hernandez seems more like the 4th receiver and flex guy.

Keller prob leads Jets in receptions.

Why restrict yourself to one only for the rest of the season? Limited transaction league?

think im gonna drop jermaine gresham for chris cooley

I think Shaun Hill has the best matchup, so I'd take him. I thought he played as good as the other 2 tonight. (not that that's saying much.)

also, LOL

I'm in a 2-QB league and was going to post this very question. Play Hasselbeck at home vs SD, or Michael Vick as a backup/wildcat QB?

because im planning to use the waiver wire to pick one of them up and will try to pick another during FA. sad thing is i dont think i can pick up Keller since i dropped him last week...

Weekly widely available DEF discussion for anyone playing best available each week:
I'm using <40% owned in Yahoo leagues.
*estimated line for opposing Team total in ()

TB v PIT(17) - Leftwich starting?
WAS @ STL(17)
CIN @ CAR(18) - Claussen starting

.... deeper teams available

IND @ DEN(21)
OAK @ ARZ(22) - Anderson starting
NYG v TEN(20) - VY starting

... really deep

CLE @ BAL(24) - not following flacco's troubles
ARZ v OAK(18) - Gradkowski starting? torched last week

Meh not going any deeper than that. Not really giving advice as much as I am posting what should be available to stimulate discussion for people who add/drop based on matchups each week. I'm leaning towards TB, but any of those top 3 look decent and should be available.

I think its a pretty clear toss-up b/w hasselbeck and hill, and I'd go with hasselbeck at home over hill in MIN. Both will likely be throwing a lot as their teams will be down, but I think there is a better chance that DET is down because of Hill, but both obv. have a good shot at this.

I'd go with hasselbeck

Bengals imo, TB good one too.

This is how I feel too.

Worth dropping Gresham for Keller?

Have first waiver pick up, need pretty much anyone, favre sucks, grants got hurt, crabtree-colston not doing much. I'm thinking of going RB, 20 yards/pt, no ppr.

Hills, Tolbert, or Snelling?

WR get 10 yrd/pt, but there are no real good options out there

Along lines of post above.

I have TUrner and #1 waiver. Should I be hedging my bets and getting snelling or going all in on Tolbert. Also, hopefully Hillis will be around for round 2 of waiver wire (the only other people I think that pay attention to the waiver wire are loaded at RB)

Why go Tolbert when it looks like Mathews is going to be fine?

Is Favre droppable for any of these guys off the wire? I have Eli as my QB1...

Stafford
Orton
Hasselbeck
Vick

How many weeks before it's sane to drop Crabtree? I was thinking 4

Is garcon droppable yet?

I have lots of dead weight that I need to address:

Pierre Garcon
Mike Crabtree
Jamaal Charles (good player but Todd Haley doesn't want to give him more than 10 touches per game, wtf)
Zach Miller
_____

So I am thinking of picking up Jason Snelling and Demaryius Thomas and Dustin Keller/Aaron Hernandez. Good idea?

waaaay too soon of Charles. Demaryius is probably already better than Garcon and Crabtree. Guy is a freak.

4pt passing tds

Orton vs Indy
or
Kolb @ Jac

Brent Celek @ Jac
or
Marcedes Lewis vs Philly
or try to get Hernandez off waivers dropping either Celek or Lewis?

Dude Favre is playing the Lions.

12-team league. 6 points per TD, bonus points for long TDs. No PPR.

Pick one for defense:

Bucs v. Pit
Rams v. Was
Cards v. Oak
Was @ Rams
Cin @ Car
Oak @ Ari

Pick 1 Flex:

Jonathan Stewart v. Cin
Fred Taylor v. Buf (note: looks like Kevin Faulk is out this week)
Nate Washington @ NYG
Mike Thomas v. Phi