Keeper rules:
5 keepers kept, at least 1 hitter and 1 pitcher
Keeper cost: The 1st year a player is kept they cost the round they were drafted in.
2nd year: +1 round earlier
3rd year: +3 rounds earlier
4th year: +6 rounds earlier
5th year: +10 rounds earlier
If you do not have the draft pick to keep that player, you may keep that player for +1 earlier round. If you do not have the earlier draft pick, it takes the next earliest round. For example, John Doe is a 6th rder, but you traded your 6th and 5th pick, John Doe costs you a 4th rder.
You may keep a MAX of 2 players per round.

If you trade for a player, his keeper cost is the round he was drafted in.
If you pick up a player from FA who was drafted, his keeper cost is the round he was drafted in.
If you pick up a player from FA who was NOT drafted, his keeper cost is the last drafting round.
A max of 3 FA's who were not drafted may be kept per year.
Keepers can be kept for a max of 5 years

Can someone list the guys that have already been kept five years and will be back in the draft pool? It makes a difference in selecting my keepers. I could do it myself, but as has already been proven in the thread multiple times, I lack clarity on the situation and got mixed responses that didn’t help.

FWIW I don't think those are correct rounds as 5th year is +10 rounds, so if they were 14/15th last year I believe they would be 4/5th this year.

Keeper rules:
5 keepers kept, at least 1 hitter and 1 pitcher
Keeper cost: The 1st year a player is kept they cost the round they were drafted in.
2nd year: +1 round earlier
3rd year: +3 rounds earlier
4th year: +6 rounds earlier
5th year: +10 rounds earlier

Anyone in this list with a year 5, 5th, or 5 after their name goes back into keeper pool this year... all others won't be known until keepers are finalized, so you have to make educated guesses to come up with a list for example... I can keep Scherzer in the 1st, but 99% chance I won't be given no value in doing so, so he will be available.

Hurp Durpington:
Patrick Corbin - 17th - 1st
Juan Soto - 25th - 1st
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. -21st - 1st
Cody Bellinger - 15th - 1st
Tommy Pham - 13rd - 2nd

I Raze River
Trout (1) 5th
Correa (15)4th
Syndergaard (14) 4th
Flaherty (23) 1st
Carpenter (12) 1st

cs3's Keepers:
Judge 25 - 2nd
Ramirez 9 - 2nd
deGrom 6 - 5th
Story 5 - 1st
Freeman 2 - 1st

movieman's keepers:
Acuna 25th 2nd
Blackmon 6th (5th year)
Snell 13th 1st
Bauer 11th 1st
Aguilar 26th 1st

CharlieKelly
Zack Wheeler - 18th - 1st
German Marquez - 19th - 1st
Kyler Tucker - 20th - 1st
Eddie Rosario - 21st - 2nd
Matt Chapman - 22nd - 1st

Kinslers List
Nolan Arrendado 1st (5th)
Eloy Jimenez 18th 1st year
Fernando Tatis Jr. 26th 1st year
Victor Robles 19th 1st year
Kirby Yates 25th 1st

DontDoItPls
Max Scherzer (1)
Javier Baez (9) 1st year
Trea Turner (12) 3rd year
Eugenio Suarez (14) 1st year
Joey Gallo (25) 2nd year

Yankeys
Khris Davis (4th Round Pick) - 2nd
Rhys Hoskins (25th Round Pick) - 2nd
Michael Conforto (19th Round Pick) - 1st
Walker Buehler (24th Round Pick) - 1st
Miles Mikolas (23rd Round Pick) 1st

NDFan
JD Martinez 17th (year 5)
Alex Bregman 22nd (year 3)
Nicholas Castellanos 14th (year 2)
Aaron Nola 8th (year 2)
Gerrit Cole 5th (year 1)

Dark Knight
Gleyber Torres (17th) - 1st
Nick Senzel (19th) - 1st
Aldaberto Mondesi (26th) - 1st
Michael Brantley (26th) - 1st
Tyler Glasnow (23rd) - 1st

danvh
Betts - 7th - 5th
Lindor - 12th - 4th
Yelich - 5th - 5th
Sale 1st - 1st
Severino 26th - 2nd

I think it's +10 from the original round they were kept?

Nearly positive this is the rule

Thinking more I am pretty sure Syndergaard was a 22nd round pick. Year 1-22, year 2-21, year 3-18, year 4-15, which would make year 5-11.

I know for certain he was drafted and not a waiver pickup

Maybe I'm wrong. That doesn't make sense. Clarification needed

Javier Baez on the block. He can be kept in the 8th round (2nd year keeper).

Looking for a 6th rounder.

Anyone need an elite closer?

Kirby Yates rd 24 keeper
Nick Anderson rd 26 keeper

Both available for a draft pick(s).

Nope its not from original, it would be from prior year.

I really don't think this correct after thinking about it. Can you see all of our draft results from past years on the desktop? Can't find it on mobile. If Syndergaard was actually a 22nd round pick as I believe he would have been 12th round keeper last year.

I'll probably have time to back through the thread and investigate tomorrow if movie doesn't chime in on the matter

It's from the prior year.
The number of rounds the player jumps increases each year.

For some reason this league does not have any archived data from prior seasons. In all my other Yahoo leagues, on the main page there is a drop down menu where you can change the year and view draft results, message board, transactions, etc from every previous season. Not sure why but that's not available in this league.
But I'm 100% certain that the round bumps listed are from the prior season, not from the original keeper round.

Like I said I'm going to look through the keeper lists from years past tomorrow.

I can see I'm outnumbered, but I'm stubborn lol. Fully admit I trust my own memory to a fault sometimes.

I'll compile some data to sort out what the precedent is

Correct that it's the prior year. I have a Google Doc that I think a couple guys are shared on that has every year.

Also, do you know why the bolded would be true? Is it something I can change in the settings or something?

I alwyas thought it was just automatically available so idk. I commish a couple keeper leagues and I don't remember ever having to set anything up but ill look through the settings on both of those and see if I can find anything

Ok so

Correa(5) 5th
Syndergaard (4) 5th
Lamet (26) 1st

Are available

Likely keepers barring injury or trade.

Flaherty (22) 2nd
Alonso (11) 1st
Y. Alvarez (26) 1st
Luis Robert (25) 1st
Lamet (24) 1st

Since no bites... Trea Turner now on the block. Can be kept in the 6th round (4th year) keeper.

Looking to get a 4th rounder or best offer.

When are keepers due?

Let’s say March 13th. Just need a couple days to input stuff

Also how would folks feel about starting up a Slack for the league? A few other leagues some of us are in have moved to slack and it’s way easier and more fun

Whatis slack?

Slack is an app that is essentially a better way for the league to communicate.

Cool with slack group. Already use it for work and group texts

Movie,

Has everyone confirmed they are in this year?

I’ve had ppl convince me to discord, Telegraph, WhatsApp... why is there always something new?