Quote:
Originally Posted by Karak
Kendry Morales is overpaid at 3.9
Carlos Gonzalez is about right at 3.1, maybe slightly overpaid.
Montero is overpaid... so is Suzuki.
The difference between a low-end top 10 catcher and a top 20 or 30 catcher is not very big.
Catcher, fantasy wise, goes like this: Mauer >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> like 2-3 other names (none of the names on your team) >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> a few others >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> everyone else
Your pitching is very good and assuming a swap with Levarkin it will only get better... however pitching is a lot easier to platoon and acquire in this league than hitting.
Here comes the obligatory gonna defend yourself? then your gonna have to educate response....
I said top 10 b/c I knew if I said top 6 somebody would say eh I don't think so. Yahoo has Suzuki ranked at 3 and Montero at 6 in 2009 season totals for catchers. And yeah there's a big difference Suzuki stole 8 bases, which only Russell Martin stole more (11). Think thats not a big deal? Thats how categories are won, not with 1 big giant base stealer when damn near everybody on your team steals bases. Look at my team and tell me if I can steal bases? Thats why I went to $1 mil on the guy, when I probably should have focused in on a better closer.
Montero is not overpaid he's the only catcher not named Mauer or Weiters or McCann or Napoli that hits 15+ HRs with a high SLG% (oh btw Suzuki hit 15 HRs last yr along with those 8 SBs..... seriously where are these top 20 and 30 catchers who can do that???). And unlike Napoli he'll log more than 125 games this year. I got 2 guys there so I'll get 162 games from my catcher position. 162 quality games.
Kendry Morales is overpaid at $3.9 mil??? This is a guy who was 6th last year in SLG... SIXTH!!! and tied for 14th in HRs..... .355 OBP with 86 runs and 3 SBs for good measure. From a kid who's only 26. In 3 years he'll still be killing it and I'll be paying him less than $5 mil. Meanwhile you're paying Chipper Jones $4.7 mil, Rickie Weeks $5.2 mil, Jose Reyes $9.1 mil, Nick Markakis $6.5 mil, Dan Uggla $5.9 mil.... I mean take your pick there all of those signings are horrific compared to Morales. None of those guys are top 6 in anything, probably not even top 14. I guess Reyes in SBs (if he's healthy).
Carlos Gonzalez is a pimp. I don't even have to say anything about him. He's like a mini Matt Kemp. I'm VERY happy with that signing.
We said this was going to be a smack talking league so I didn't hold anything back. Go ahead rip me back