Quote:
Originally Posted by mongidig
I am. Keep in mind I am just starting to think this. I've seen many times when a QB has a good rookie year and then defenses catch up to him and it doesn't go so well. Remember Davis Mills? In small sample sizes I think players aren't as good or as bad as we have seen up to this point. Stroud has not looked good to me this whole year even with Nico. He looks slow running the ball. I kind of liked what I saw from Bryce in the Bronco game. I think he is in a tough situation to start his career and I feel like he will get it going at some point. I would still take Stroud over him but I don't like petite QB's. It will be interesting to see what happens if Carolina puts a team around Bryce or they ship him to another team. I don't think he'll ever be a star but he could have a Geno like career. Stroud has a higher ceiling but I have a feeling they will end up being about the same. So much goes into a QB's surroundings. I think Caleb will follow the Lawrence arc. He'll leave you wanting more. The Bears need to clean house with their coaches/executives etc. Caleb has no chance with this Bears staff. Bo Nix has landed in a perfect spot with fantastic coaching. Unfortunately, he has very little talent surrounding him. The fact that he is thriving here is impressive.
I think Bryce is still live to have better fantasy seasons than Stroud but better irl QB he's going to have to put some insane film up.
Timestamped at just before 9min
https://youtu.be/Lv8AVVTBMEw?list=PL...4Fewku05&t=537
This type of stuff is littered across CJ's rookie tape. This is a gift that you don't forget, his apptitude and mechanics are off the charts and I don't think this just disappears. Anticipation is why guys like Fields are never going to be quality QB's and because of Bryce's height he cannot work the middle of the field as often as CJ. I want to say CJ is the next coming of Peyton Manning but I'm starting to get the feeling he's just a ho-hum 4,000/30 type guy. He should have 5,000/40 in him but not sure if Houston is going to let him. I've been lazy to watch film this year so I can't comment on CJ's struggles this year beyond having a slightly better WR corps than the Raiders due to injuries but at the level I hype him he should be able to overcome it.
Anyways, as a fantasy QB I think his ceiling is capped but there can only be a handful of QB's ahead of him who you would want at the helm of your franchise irl.