Quote:
Originally Posted by BGnight
Why? Penny has way more upside. He's the most talented RB on SEA. He may not play much first couple games but Kamara's situation last year was similar.
Seattle is a mess and Penny is nowhere near Kamara level from anything that I’ve seen. Didn’t think he was anywhere near worth a 1st rounder (though it only matters what SEA thinks, not me of course). Carroll sure does seem to be deeply in love with Carson for whatever reason.
Breida is the most talented back in SF as well, though his size certainly may work against him in terms of potential workload.
Don’t think they’re too far apart, but I’ll take the guy with the clearer line to touches in the better setup for success. You might be right that Penny has more upside due to him being more likely to be able to carry a full load at some point though so maybe I’m dumb.