Quote:
Originally Posted by mgv1208
Lamb is not better than either beltre or turner...
Pineda is = to melancon (maybe melancon is slightly better)
Piscotty is way better than Kepler
Maybe altuve is further apart from turner than beltre from lamb and that makes this trade uneven
Lamb is most definitely worth a lot more than Beltre. Dude just missed 2 months because hes so damn old, and even if he comes back 100% healthy he has zero chance to do what Lamb has done over the past 2 months. Going forward, I strongly believe that Lamb is just flat out better.
Turner's value is debateable, but I would never give up Lamb for him straight up. Granted, I've been lower on Turner all along, going back to last season, but so far his struggles have been proving me right. In either case, its not debatable that Lamb is a much much better hitter right now.
And Altuve is so far ahead of any of them that your offer is rather laughable to be honest.
Pineda probably is worth a little more than Melancon, but they are minor pieces.
And Piscotty and and Kepler are totally inconsequential in this trade.