Some of you may remember a prop bet in the hu forum where 2 players played hu 1 had a random hand and the other had AA every hand. As I recall AA won but it was a close match. My question is who would win if 2 players played hu and 1 had AA and the other had 4 random carda playing holdem nl. Such that the player w 4 random hands would have the benefit of playing blockers and would know what his opponent is holding?? On the other hand AA could go all in every hand pf and might have an edge hu but if the player played 4 hands in the pot he would have to risk 4 to win 1 but might be a favorite since the more players in a pot the less likely it is that AA would win.

I would like to hear opinions on who would be most likely to win and what the best strategy is for both players.

I’m not exactly sure what type of matchup you’re proposing, but faceup AA should get destroyed postflop against a 100% range and large stacks.