Join Date: Oct 2013
Posts: 326
I haven't ran the hand through a solver, but I like the preflop call of the 4-bet most of the time when you're that deep. I actually like calling more against tight players who will stack off when you hit a set.
I would likely call the flop bet as well against most players.
Your 3-bet frequency is relevant because I would expect him to 4-bet wider if you're an aggressive 3-better. So if you 3-bet a lot preflop that weighs in favor of continuing against the flop bet, assuming he is aware enough to be adjusting. If he still 4-bets super tight pre even though you 3-bet wide then I would just fold to the flop bet.
However if his 4-bet percentage is reasonably wide I'm thinking you have to continue on the flop. You can win at showdown sometimes when he gives up on his bluffs, and there are turns that give you additional equity to continue if he keeps barreling.
Now I will give the disclaimer that I may be wrong, but I want to test myself before someone else runs it through a solver.