Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
couple of quick questions couple of quick questions

12-24-2010 , 01:32 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by sh58
you are right that those things are mostly known by the NL200 grinder, but the NL200 might also teach some bad habits. in chess i'm sure that a 1900 player will be able to improve me a tonne, but an IM would just be so so much better, assuming again that he can teach as well. the 1900 might teach me bad habits etc, that hamper my progress.
I think most people just want to save you from wasting money when they were giving you advice. $60 is quite a lot for chess lessons. You should definitely consider Ben Finegold if you're going to pay that much. He has a ton of experience with weak players and is a good teacher. I don't know if I can say this (sorry mods, if not) but YouKnowWho is an FM here who used to give lessons for a lot less and you'd get just as much out of his lessons.

I'm not nearly good enough at poker to comment on learning poker, but chess learning seems to be more layered. Like you have to learn the basics before you can understand the next level and so on. And it takes a fair bit of time to learn the basics. So as long as you find someone who knows what the basics are and can kinda teach you, the rest doesn't matter much. I guess you do have to know a certain amount to figure out what that basic knowledge is.

ETA - keep in mind that chess lessons are normally a LOT more frequent and go on for a lot longer than typical poker lessons.
couple of quick questions Quote
12-24-2010 , 01:35 AM
And the problem is that advanced chess knowledge is a sucker's bet. You can read a book or take a lesson from a really advanced player, and everything they say will make perfect sense to you and you'll feel like you are making a ton of progress.

But with a board and an opponent in front of you, you won't be able to apply those advanced ideas to your games. It just won't work for you without the basics. It feels like chess is a game of acquired knowledge, but it's really a game of acquired skill, which is slightly but importantly different.
couple of quick questions Quote

      
m