Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Why do you care about truth? Why do you care about truth?

03-14-2010 , 05:45 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
In another thread ILP commented something about truth and it got me thinking again why do any of us care about truth?

Does holding truth have any real value? If life ends when you die and the actual truth would make your life more difficult, why would you want it?

Shouldn't we be more concerned with what makes our lives as enjoyable as possible? Is truth guaranteed to accomplish that?
i dont think anything is guaranteed to accomplish that, but given the choice between truth and delusion, i think truth is more likely to make our lives easier, happier, etc.

but theres plenty of people who seem quite content in delusion. so i guess its hard to say.
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 05:50 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by madnak
How on earth did you get that out of his post?
Am I screwing up, or am I in some kind of twilight zone? What do you mean how did I get that? Did you read the OP?

Did I?

[cue twilight zone theme]
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 06:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lestat
Am I screwing up, or am I in some kind of twilight zone? What do you mean how did I get that? Did you read the OP?

Did I?

[cue twilight zone theme]
No...he didn't.

It's obvious that he didn't read it or his reading comprehension skills are poor.
But he is funny.... he makes a good joke to get the cool kids to think he's cool.
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 06:17 PM
JD, I think a basic amount of curtesy is appropriate. I would not accept that from you if you were sitting at my table and if this were my thread, id ask you to leave. Its not, so instead ill make this comment and leave it at that.

In other words. Make a point, pursue an argument and stop the ****ing ad hominims?
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 06:46 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
Have I ever talked about imposing my beliefs or morals on anyone? If someone comes to me for advise I might share it, but I am wildly against trying to govern other people morally.
The Bible isn't against governing other people morally. Is the Bible true?
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 07:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lestat
Am I screwing up, or am I in some kind of twilight zone? What do you mean how did I get that? Did you read the OP?

Did I?

[cue twilight zone theme]
He's saying that he cares a lot about the truth, but that he's not so sure that it's a good thing. He has described himself as "addicted" to truth, so I'd say it's pretty important to him.
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 07:14 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tao1
JD, I think a basic amount of curtesy is appropriate. I would not accept that from you if you were sitting at my table and if this were my thread, id ask you to leave. Its not, so instead ill make this comment and leave it at that.

In other words. Make a point, pursue an argument and stop the ****ing ad hominims?
Yes... just like you did here?

You realize how stupid you look when you do things like this?
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 07:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dying Actors
i dont think anything is guaranteed to accomplish that, but given the choice between truth and delusion, i think truth is more likely to make our lives easier, happier, etc.

but theres plenty of people who seem quite content in delusion. so i guess its hard to say.
But I think that sometimes we can see what is more likely the truer path and that if we choose it it will make our lives more difficult. I think that you are probably right that nothing is guaranteed to make our lives easier and that it is probably a mash of both truth and constructed truth.
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 07:22 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by madnak
He's saying that he cares a lot about the truth, but that he's not so sure that it's a good thing. He has described himself as "addicted" to truth, so I'd say it's pretty important to him.
This was exactly what I was saying. Lestat, I will not comment on your post as I feel Madnak said it as well as I could.
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 07:24 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JoeyDiamonds
Yes... just like you did here?

You realize how stupid you look when you do things like this?
do you realize how stupid you look? theres a reason no one (atheist or theist) comes to support you on your behalf ... and its not cause they are jealous of your humor.
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 07:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by madnak
I think one of the reasons I get along with you better than most theists is that you seem to look for the "real" truth instead of whatever "truth" makes you most comfortable.
Thank you. That means a lot to me coming from you.
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 07:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by dknightx
do you realize how stupid you look? theres a reason no one (atheist or theist) comes to support you on your behalf ... and its not cause they are jealous of your humor.
The difference is that I don't need e-friends with multiple accounts to be "cool" on an internet forum.... like you.



(Now switch accounts and say "Yea....JD is stupid)

Stop derailing this thread...stay on topic or just pm me your insults.
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 07:30 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by nittyit
The Bible isn't against governing other people morally. Is the Bible true?
What the bible is doing is completely different. Now I am not convinced that the bible is disagreeing with your examples, but that is another story.

If the bible is truth then it is not about trying to govern people, but about informing them of the truth. If I told you that putting your hand in the fire will burn you and you shouldn't do that, would you really respond "stop trying to govern me you bastard!"
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 07:36 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JoeyDiamonds
The difference is that I don't need e-friends with multiple accounts to be "cool" on an internet forum.... like you.
i know you are trying hard to not expose that idiotic side of yours, but unfortunately when you make ******ed statements like this, its just plainly obvious to everyone that you are just stupid. cant really say it any nicer than that.

if you actually think I have multiple accounts on this forum, id be more than happy to wager as much money as you can muster together.
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 07:39 PM
Ok you guys let's stop the derail, we had a good thread going on here with good discussion. Thank you.
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 07:48 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dying Actors
i dont think anything is guaranteed to accomplish that, but given the choice between truth and delusion, i think truth is more likely to make our lives easier, happier, etc.

but theres plenty of people who seem quite content in delusion. so i guess its hard to say.
You are dead wrong, and it is not even close.
Truth is dangerous and deadly. To live a happy life, you have to plunge into a delusion (of various kinds, spiritual, religious, emotional, academic and even philosophical or scientific, I mean look at all those geniuses in the thread looking for the "truth" out there).
But, of course, as Nietzsche once said, "Men do not seek happiness, Englishmen do."
Cheers
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 07:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by damaci
You are dead wrong, and it is not even close.
Truth is dangerous and deadly. To live a happy life, you have to plunge into a delusion (of various kinds, spiritual, religious, emotional, academic and even philosophical or scientific, I mean look at all those geniuses in the thread looking for the "truth" out there).
But, of course, as Nietzsche once said, "Men do not seek happiness, Englishmen do."
Cheers
Nietzsche also said "You need chaos in your soul to give birth to a dancing star."

He was a nut case.
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 08:36 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
.... but about informing them of the truth. If I told you that putting your hand in the fire will burn you and you shouldn't do that, would you really respond "stop trying to govern me you bastard!"
i mean really.. you're talking about preventing a burn in the same breath as everything laid out in the bible?
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 08:38 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
Ok you guys let's stop the derail, we had a good thread going on here with good discussion. Thank you.
tbf, joey doesn't seem to exit stage left until someone berates him directly about how big of a troll he comes off as.
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 08:40 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Butcho22
tbf, joey doesn't seem to exit stage left until someone berates him directly about how big of a troll he comes off as.
Stay on topic and stop trying to be cool.... it doesn't work for you.
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 08:52 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
But I think that sometimes we can see what is more likely the truer path and that if we choose it it will make our lives more difficult. I think that you are probably right that nothing is guaranteed to make our lives easier and that it is probably a mash of both truth and constructed truth.
You're sort of alluding to a kind of Noble Lie. The problem is, while it may seem at first that the lie will make us happier, we can't know in advance at what point our leading ourselves astray will bite us in the ass. Hence my comment about seeking the truth being +EV. Seeking and following the truth (as much as we can figure it out) is simply more reliable, and allows us to make better decisions.
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 09:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Arouet
You're sort of alluding to a kind of Noble Lie. The problem is, while it may seem at first that the lie will make us happier, we can't know in advance at what point our leading ourselves astray will bite us in the ass. Hence my comment about seeking the truth being +EV. Seeking and following the truth (as much as we can figure it out) is simply more reliable, and allows us to make better decisions.
Very nice. I agree with Aro 100% here.

What did you do Jib that you don't want to tell someone about?
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 09:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
Have I ever talked about imposing my beliefs or morals on anyone? If someone comes to me for advise I might share it, but I am wildly against trying to govern other people morally.
Quote:
Originally Posted by nittyit
The Bible isn't against governing other people morally. Is the Bible true?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
If the bible is truth then it is not about trying to govern people, but about informing them of the truth. If I told you that putting your hand in the fire will burn you and you shouldn't do that, would you really respond "stop trying to govern me you bastard!"
We're talking morals here. Didn't we get our morality from the Bible? There is a consequence for not adhering to the morals that have been laid out in the Bible. That is morally governing someone.
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 09:28 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
why do any of us care about truth?
Because some of us like to dream about the unattainable.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
Does holding truth have any real value?


Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
Shouldn't we be more concerned with what makes our lives as enjoyable as possible
Sounds cool to me

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
Is truth guaranteed to accomplish that?
Truth is unattainable. However experience has shown us that some belief systems are particularly well suited to solving practical problems. I suspect that in the main using them leads to greater enjoyment in life.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
If life ends when you die and the actual truth would make your life more difficult, why would you want it?
Depends on you. Difficult to control exactly what you believe. Some people do not get contentment from an easy life.

Also if you do not believe death is the end, and follow this to its logical conclusion then act on those conclusions, you could end up doing some really silly things. Still many people seem to manage the delicate balancing act of while believing something, nether the less not actually using that belief to make any real world decisions.
Why do you care about truth? Quote
03-14-2010 , 09:53 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by madnak
He's saying that he cares a lot about the truth, but that he's not so sure that it's a good thing. He has described himself as "addicted" to truth, so I'd say it's pretty important to him.
You're scaring me dude. Mainly, because I consider you to be more astute and sharper than I am. Here's the OP in its entirety...

Quote:
In another thread ILP commented something about truth and it got me thinking again why do any of us care about truth?

Does holding truth have any real value? If life ends when you die and the actual truth would make your life more difficult, why would you want it?

Shouldn't we be more concerned with what makes our lives as enjoyable as possible? Is truth guaranteed to accomplish that?


Where does he even come close to mentioning he cares about the truth let alone its importance?

Now I admit that I haven't read every single one of Jib's posts in this thread. But from the OP and his response to me, NOWHERE does he leave the impression that the truth is important to him! On the contrary, he seems to be questioning the value of truth!

Should I start making reservations at Hotel Silly? Because I'm definitely not seeing what you're seeing. If I'm missing it, I apologize in advance. I must be over stressed from playing too much online poker lately.

[Edit:] The only thing I can think of is that I'm confusing Jibninjas with another poster with a similar name (jibanias, or something like that?) I don't think so, because I usually recognize avatars more than names.
Why do you care about truth? Quote

      
m