Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God

06-18-2010 , 08:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Weatherhead03
This is my last post for a few hours, I have to run out but ill be back later.

You are calling me a hypocrite?? You are asking me for odds??? All this after you said that there are no smart theists and that if you believe in God you are dumb.

Why would I give you odds?? It sounds like you think this is a slam dunk. If you are so smart and theists are so dumb it should be like taking candy from a baby.
Because you're making me go up against 2 people in an IQ test (which isn't even a true measure of intelligence, but the closest thing we have), and there's variance involved, AND you get to hand pick whomever you want from this forum? You're the one who initially proposed the prop bet, not me.

I'll consider doing it for 1:1 odds pending I get at least 10k in action from the forum. I'm going out as well, so if anyone wants action (we will write up rules etc. if there is enough interest), post in this thread with the $$ u want in action.

Also, on my success prop bet which was outlined earlier, I'm willing to offer 2:1 odds in your favor that I have both more $$ AND have made more $$ from legitimate sources
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:13 PM
5cent, you have an incredibly biased opinion. It is blinding you so much it is causing you to see things that are not even there.
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:15 PM
I never took anyone's word for it. I told you, I did my own research and came to my own conclusion. Do you have reading comprehension problems? Here's the research I've done. #1 Research about the universe. The universe is massive. There are approx 100 billion stars (each with many planets) in ONE galaxy, and approx 100 billion galaxies in the known universe. Given this information, the probability of life is 100%, and the probability of complex life is extremely likely. Given that information, it also proves that humans are in no way significant in terms of the universe...to think we are significant in any way is thinking from 500+ years ago. Moreover, I play poker. I therefore know what variance is. Variance explains everything that's happened in the universe 100x better than theories about god could have

Now stop dodging my heaven question
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gunth0807
What is so funny? I know why you think it is funny, but i want to hear it from you.
I can tell you why I think it's funny. It's because if your parents were Islamic, you would have searched for the truth and would now be a practicing Muslim. If your parents were Jewish, you'd be a Jew. If your parents were Hindu, you'd be...
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:17 PM
lol, i think i can safely bet that dknightx has a smile on his face.
Quote:
there are only 2 "regular" theist posters on this board that i think may have a higher IQ than you. but what exactly does that prove? smart theists dont tend to post on RGT for many reasons.
Quote:
It proves that I am smarter than any regular theist on this forum
Quote:
I never took anyone's word for it.

Last edited by Gunth0807; 06-18-2010 at 08:22 PM.
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:18 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lestat
I can tell you why I think it's funny. It's because if your parents were Islamic, you would have searched for the truth and would now be a practicing Muslim. If your parents were Jewish, you'd be a Jew. If your parents were Hindu, you'd be...
Yup i must of just got lucky...
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gunth0807
lol, i think i can safely bet that dknightx has a smile on his face.
actually im in a meeting so no.

but what would i be smiling at?
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:20 PM
Thanks Gunth for showing your Holier than Thou attitude - what am i seeing thats not there? Do you want me to dig up what ive read on your thoughts about Jews & Nazi's? Classrooms of kids about to die unless you manned up? You only wanting to hear scripture? You saying you haven't gone missionary yet due to personal issues? You asking some people not to post in your threads? GET SOME HELP MAN!!
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:22 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by einbert
There actually are some Christians that are a tad smarter than Gunth and Splendour, but basically zero that are as smart as even the lowest of scientists.
C'mon... You guys are pushing this way too far. There are plenty of intelligent Christians and other religious people. It's perfectly legitimate to ask why this is so. But (in my opinion) it hurts your credibility to claim 99.99% of all religious people are stupid. This clearly is not the case and again, it destroys your credibility in any other arguments you might want to make.
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:22 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by dknightx
actually im in a meeting so no.

but what would i be smiling at?
I edited to show.
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:24 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lestat
C'mon... You guys are pushing this way too far. There are plenty of intelligent Christians and other religious people. It's perfectly legitimate to ask why this is so. But (in my opinion) it hurts your credibility to claim 99.99% of all religious people are stupid. This clearly is not the case and again, it destroys any other credible arguments you might want to make.
Your guy's only argument for me being stupid is i am stupid because i believe in God.
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gunth0807
Your guy's only argument for me being stupid is i am stupid because i believe in God.
If you can say that itt then that should be proof enough.
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gunth0807
Your guy's only argument for me being stupid is i am stupid because i believe in God.
come on now, you cant really believe this can you? I dont think Aaron W, Jibs, bigpooch, etc, etc are stupid, and they probably believe in God *more* than you. I'm sure most atheists who think you are stupid believe the same.
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:26 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 5cent
Thanks Gunth for showing your Holier than Thou attitude - what am i seeing thats not there? Do you want me to dig up what ive read on your thoughts about Jews & Nazi's? Classrooms of kids about to die unless you manned up? You only wanting to hear scripture? You saying you haven't gone missionary yet due to personal issues? You asking some people not to post in your threads? GET SOME HELP MAN!!
Lets see you stick around the next few months getting attacked by lie after lie while people just mess with you for the hell of it over and over again.
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by batair
If you can say that itt then that should be proof enough.
Your opinion, but it is not based on anything.
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:28 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by dknightx
come on now, you cant really believe this can you? I dont think Aaron W, Jibs, bigpooch, etc, etc are stupid, and they probably believe in God *more* than you. I'm sure most atheists who think you are stupid believe the same.
My name has been wrongfully slandered since day 1. You know it, i know it, and every person involved knows it. And almost every insult has been based on that.

I can spend my next few months calling someone an idiot after everything someone posts and i think it will catch on too. But it is not honest and it is disrespectful.
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:30 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by SixT4
Unintelligent generalisations ITT.
+1

And I can't help pointing out how atheists don't clam up just because it's another atheist making a ridiculous claim. This is far different than in Gunth's OP where I didn't see too many Christians lambasting the idea that not killing 1 person to save the lives of many was ridiculous.
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:32 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gunth0807
Your opinion, but it is not based on anything.
You say the only reason people say you're dumb is because you believe in God in a thread where most of the atheists are arguing and trying to bet money belief in God doesn't in and of itself make people dumb. Im not sure what other conclusion i could make.
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:33 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lestat
+1

And I can't help pointing out how atheists don't clam up just because it's another atheist making a ridiculous claim. This is far different than in Gunth's OP where I didn't see too many Christians lambasting the idea that not killing 1 person to save the lives of many was ridiculous.

This is a super rare instance where atheists are not letting a ridiculous claim by another atheist slide.

I was completely open to discussion in that thread with other theists. I actually wanted that to take place so i can gain a bigger perspective.
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:34 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gunth0807
Lets see you stick around the next few months getting attacked by lie after lie while people just mess with you for the hell of it over and over again.
whats that got to do with the price of 2 fish and 5 loaves?
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:34 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by batair
You say the only reason people say you're dumb is because you believe in God in a thread where most of the atheists are arguing and trying to bet money belief in God doesn't in and of itself make people dumb. Im not sure what other conclusion i could make.
Please read post 217.
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gunth0807
Please read post 217.
This post is the one i was responding to.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gunth0807
Your guy's only argument for me being stupid is i am stupid because i believe in God.
This in a thread where atheists are arguing the opposite.

So i have two choices. One your an idiot or two you are pretending to be one. I lean to the second one fwiw.
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:46 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by batair
This post is the one i was responding to.

In a thread where atheists are arguing the opposite.

So i have two choices. One your an idiot or two you are pretending to be one. I lean to the second one fwiw.
You are an idiot.

They are referring to other people, not me.
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:48 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gunth0807
You are an idiot.

They are referring to other people, not me.
Wow. I stand corrected op. Never mind.
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote
06-18-2010 , 08:49 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gunth0807
I was completely open to discussion in that thread with other theists. I actually wanted that to take place so i can gain a bigger perspective.
I wasn't referring to you. You were the one asking the question, so I would expect you to play the devil's advocate and defend the contrary point of view. But other Christians should have jumped in on the side that was clearly the most rational thing to do. They did not.

Quote:
This is a super rare instance where atheists are not letting a ridiculous claim by another atheist slide.
That's the beauty of atheism and not having to defend irrational views based on some dogmatic principle. I am free to disagree whenever something doesn't make sense me. More importantly, I can also change my mind if someone else makes more sense.

This is not a rare instance. It is what it is. An unfounded claim was made that almost all religious people are stupid. There is no basis for such a claim so we reject it until evidence can be shown to back it up. Not at all unlike why we reject your religious claims. See how that works?
Serious question, how can anyone in this day and age who is somewhat intelligent believe in God Quote

      
m