Quote:
Originally Posted by NotReady
He nicked it from Patton.
If you're saying "Patton" the movie, this pre dated the movie but of course not Patton. I wouldn't say that the Army or other U.S. armed forces do not have the same perspective but in fact I believe they do.
In fact I recently heard saw a documentary of the Marine invasion of the Pacific islands in which a Marine private was disarmingly stating his feelings at Iowa Jima. He brought forth that the as an American he wasn't there to die for his Emperor as the Japanese were, but was going to satisfy the Japanese soldiers wish. Of course, I could see that the general tenor of the Marines was of this nature and could also see that the officer corps were in full agreement with him and in fact had brought this attitude into full light. The individual source( Patton or not) was moot.
As an aside but the real import of the message is; most speakers of the role of the servicemen in the world speak of the obligation of "dying for one's country" as a fact, like a fact of nature. The "Charge of the Light Brigade" is the picture of this elan or bravado in the world of global militarism. To hear this coming from a Marine drill instructor at the first day of Marine training can be a great light in the psyche of the new Marine or any other military service .
He can conclude that the U.S. Marine Corps wasn't in the business of doing anything stupid, or dying for the sake of dying like some aberrant charge justified by "dying for one's country". This is a great relief which can buoy one into the future. Of course many Marines and American servicemen, and indeed other countries servicemen died in these wars which are trenchant symbols of the tragedy and degradation of the human being within the ethos of our time. Nuff said.