Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
"If Jesus wasn't ressurected, how come so many reported it" "If Jesus wasn't ressurected, how come so many reported it"

05-11-2010 , 05:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gunth0807
Jesus is confirming the existence of certain people of the Bible. Including Adam and Eve. We are not on equal footing here.
wrong. you clearly do not understand the meaning of "confirming the existence of". If you mean that Jesus confirmed that certain people are referenced in the OT literature, then I agree with you. He in no way confirms that these people actually existed, and if they did, that their story is 100% literal, factual, or historical.

Quote:
If you are going to make an argument on a forum, you should really back it up. It is not my job to back up your argument for you. (but say please and i might do it if it is possible...)
i am no making an argument. I'm asking you why you think Jesus referring to the *story* of Jonah in any way means that Jesus believes the *story* of Jonah should be taken as literal, factual, and historical. The only thing you seem to be able to muster up is that by Jesus saying that Jonah's father was XYZ that that somehow means that the story of Jonah is 100% true. Your realize that someone can reference a story, and even recite the story word for word, and even make a analogy to that story, WITHOUT THE STORY BEING TRUE? Because it looks like you don't realize that, which is why i said your life must be very confusing.
"If Jesus wasn't ressurected, how come so many reported it" Quote
05-11-2010 , 05:55 PM
Quote:
wrong. you clearly do not understand the meaning of "confirming the existence of". If you mean that Jesus confirmed that certain people are referenced in the OT literature, then I agree with you. He in no way confirms that these people actually existed, and if they did, that their story is 100% literal, factual, or historical.
Okay, so Jesus was not actually a person is what you are saying? Mary and Joseph did not exist? Their parents did not exist? and so on ?

Quote:
i am no making an argument. I'm asking you why you think Jesus referring to the *story* of Jonah in any way means that Jesus believes the *story* of Jonah should be taken as literal, factual, and historical. The only thing you seem to be able to muster up is that by Jesus saying that Jonah's father was XYZ that that somehow means that the story of Jonah is 100% true. Your realize that someone can reference a story, and even recite the story word for word, and even make a analogy to that story, WITHOUT THE STORY BEING TRUE? Because it looks like you don't realize that, which is why i said your life must be very confusing.
Jesus says the OT is The Word of God. God does not lie. He is upfront with His Creation since the Beginning.
"If Jesus wasn't ressurected, how come so many reported it" Quote
05-11-2010 , 05:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gunth0807
Once again, please provide one verse in the scripture that points to that we should not take the story literally. One verse please.

You say i am failing but i am not the one relying on insults right now to back up my argument.

Dying Actors why are you even posting in RGT if you are just going to ignore posters who think the Bible is true?
because some theists are sane, and i like discussing things with them.

as an aside, from a purely theological position, i respect your beliefs about the bible more than someone who is moderate and rational. but thats another story.
"If Jesus wasn't ressurected, how come so many reported it" Quote
05-11-2010 , 06:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dying Actors
because some theists are sane, and i like discussing things with them.

as an aside, from a purely theological position, i respect your beliefs about the bible more than someone who is moderate and rational. but thats another story.
Thanks i guess. I just try to share The Truth to the best of my abilities.
"If Jesus wasn't ressurected, how come so many reported it" Quote
05-11-2010 , 06:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gunth0807
Okay, so Jesus was not actually a person is what you are saying? Mary and Joseph did not exist? Their parents did not exist? and so on ?
thats not what I'm saying at all. I've pretty much reached the limit to my patience, and since you cant seem to comprehend anything I'm writing, it seems pointless to continue.

Quote:
Jesus says the OT is The Word of God. God does not lie. He is upfront with His Creation since the Beginning.
Taking a story in the OT as figurative, or as a spiritual metaphor, doesn't mean you believe God is a liar, or that the OT is not the Word of God.

Good luck, perhaps a regular theist on this board will feel pity or compassion for you and lend you a hand.
"If Jesus wasn't ressurected, how come so many reported it" Quote
05-11-2010 , 06:06 PM
you never answered my question Gunth, what is the heart of the earth?
"If Jesus wasn't ressurected, how come so many reported it" Quote
05-11-2010 , 06:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by MelchyBeau
you never answered my question Gunth, what is the heart of the earth?
He ignores the tough ones, but that won't stop him from chiming in with complete non sequiturs whenever the mood strikes him.
"If Jesus wasn't ressurected, how come so many reported it" Quote
05-11-2010 , 06:22 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lestat
He ignores the tough ones, but that won't stop him from chiming in with complete non sequiturs whenever the mood strikes him.
I don't ignore it, i just refrain from posting my opinion unless i am certain it is true.
"If Jesus wasn't ressurected, how come so many reported it" Quote
05-11-2010 , 06:30 PM
Quote:
thats not what I'm saying at all. I've pretty much reached the limit to my patience, and since you cant seem to comprehend anything I'm writing, it seems pointless to continue.
Uh.. yes you are:

Quote:
He in no way confirms that these people actually existed, and if they did, that their story is 100% literal, factual, or historical.
He references David. Jesus is a descendant of David. If you are denying that David was a real person, you are denying that Jesus was a real person.

Quote:
He in no way confirms that these people actually existed, and if they did, that their story is 100% literal, factual, or historical.
Yes He does, once again i am sorry you can't see the connection when the Bible tells you the connections and i am posting the connections for you.
Quote:
Taking a story in the OT as figurative, or as a spiritual metaphor, doesn't mean you believe God is a liar, or that the OT is not the Word of God.
Going to ask you one more time, can you show me one verse that points to your assumption that we should not take any of the stories literally? Dknight says so is not Scripture evidence.
Quote:
Good luck, perhaps a regular theist on this board will feel pity or compassion for you and lend you a hand.
If any theist can explain what i am saying to dknight it would be greatly appreciated as he is too smart to understand when i tell him.
"If Jesus wasn't ressurected, how come so many reported it" Quote
05-11-2010 , 06:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gunth0807
I don't ignore it, i just refrain from posting my opinion unless i am certain it is true.
Then why reference a bible verse if you don't understand it?
"If Jesus wasn't ressurected, how come so many reported it" Quote
05-11-2010 , 06:38 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by MelchyBeau
Then why reference a bible verse if you don't understand it?
I did not reference it for that reason.
"If Jesus wasn't ressurected, how come so many reported it" Quote
05-11-2010 , 07:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dying Actors
fwiw, i wasnt asking if he literally believed the story of Jonah to ridicule him. anyone who would believe that story actually happened is beyond the scope of reason to resuscitate. i just wanted to make sure i could safely ignore him in the future. and its painfully obvious that i can.
If someone tells you they believe God created the heavens and earth, is that as much of stretch as the story of Jonah? If so, should you just ignore them as well?

Peace!
"If Jesus wasn't ressurected, how come so many reported it" Quote
05-11-2010 , 07:28 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Billy5150
If someone tells you they believe God created the heavens and earth, is that as much of stretch as the story of Jonah?
no, its not. which is why in another post I said to gunth: "as an aside, from a purely theological position, i respect your beliefs about the bible more than someone who is moderate and rational."

its no stretch at all. with god, anything is possible.

Quote:
If so, should you just ignore them as well?
who is "them" ? i dont really know what you are asking, but the fact that its not a stretch to believe a man living in a whale and believing God created the heavens and the earth should give the believer more pause than it does me. i think both beliefs are insane.
"If Jesus wasn't ressurected, how come so many reported it" Quote
05-13-2010 , 04:04 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gunth0807
Jesus confirmed the story of Jonah. Or did you overlook that detail. Keep insulting yourself.

Are you able to provide anything in the Scripture that backs your claim that we should not take the story literally? Or am i just an idiot for asking this?

(Hint. My QFT did not mean quoted for truth)

Gunth0807, what did your QFT mean?

Why would you use a widely used abbreviation accepted by everyone here to mean one thing and expect anyone to think that you infact mean something else?

Why do you refuse to say what you meant by QFT?
"If Jesus wasn't ressurected, how come so many reported it" Quote
05-14-2010 , 05:09 AM
quantum field theory imo (my imo did not mean in my opinion)

Spoiler:
j/k it did

Last edited by rage4dorder; 05-14-2010 at 05:10 AM. Reason: but what does my j/k mean?
"If Jesus wasn't ressurected, how come so many reported it" Quote
05-14-2010 , 07:47 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by loveinvain
Gunth0807, what did your QFT mean?

Why would you use a widely used abbreviation accepted by everyone here to mean one thing and expect anyone to think that you infact mean something else?

Why do you refuse to say what you meant by QFT?
- He wasn't sure what QFT meant, but used it anyway.

- When it was pointed out that he managed to insult himself, he backpedaled and said that's not how he meant it.

- He now can't say how he meant it, because it would show that he wasn't even close to knowing the actual definition of QFT.

- Therefore, ignoring inquiries > embarrassment.

That's my guess anyway.
"If Jesus wasn't ressurected, how come so many reported it" Quote

      
m