Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Killing a Man in Self Defence Killing a Man in Self Defence

06-11-2010 , 01:49 PM
Quote:
I personally think you are supposed to have the faith to know God would never put you in a position to have to do this.
can you elaborate on this point? seems like millions of people are put into situations where self defense if important...
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 01:50 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Concerto
If you have a scriptural case to make, I'm listening.

An actual logical argument that is. Not just a grab bag of out-of-context verses.
I have made my case, pretty clear. I am listening to evidence to the contrary...
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 01:50 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by always_sunni_
I guess that makes sense. But Gunth is supposed to be acting like Jesus in this situation, so why should he defend himself if Jesus wouldn't?
"Acting like Jesus" is a pretty subjective concept, and it relies on human interpretation of morality. Is Gunth supposed to be a carpenter? Heal the sick? Is Gunth omniscient or omnipotent, or does Gunth have access to the same Divine information that Jesus did?

There's just no way of resolving what "Acting like Jesus" means.
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 01:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by thirddan
can you elaborate on this point? seems like millions of people are put into situations where self defense if important...
It's more like millions of people are put into situations where self defense seems important.
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 01:51 PM
Only if they are unbelievers then it should be ok.
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 01:53 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gunth0807
Scripture evidence of this claim please...

Did Jesus not scold Peter for cutting off the Roman soldiers ear?

I am going to politely ask you to not make anymore claims in this thread unless you can back it up with evidence in Scripture.
You want scripture to back up the claim that Jesus' death was important/necessary for humanity??? You are much odder than I thought.
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 01:53 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Our House
"Acting like Jesus" is a pretty subjective concept, and it relies on human interpretation of morality. Is Gunth supposed to be a carpenter? Heal the sick? Is Gunth omniscient or omnipotent, or does Gunth have access to the same Divine information that Jesus did?

There's just no way of resolving what "Acting like Jesus" means.
We all are capable of receiving the Divine information Jesus did. That is why we have God's Word. That is why we were given Jesus as an example.
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 01:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Our House
You want scripture to back up the claim that Jesus' death was important/necessary for humanity??? You are much odder than I thought.
No, actually the claim that Jesus' death was important for humanity is the only claim you have made in this thread that can be backed up by Scripture. I am talking about all your other claims.
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 02:01 PM
OIC. Okay, I'll leave the thread.
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 02:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gunth0807
It's more like millions of people are put into situations where self defense seems important.
i dont understand why you just repeated my post...
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 02:05 PM
For once I agree with Gunth. Based on the examples set in the NT (Jesus, Paul, the disciples, etc, etc) it is clear they never fought back when they were being killed (Paul being stoned many times), regardless of the reason for the attack.

If you believe in the Christian God, then you should have no worries about being attacked or killed. If God wants you to die, you'll die there, if he wants you to live, he'll "resurrect" you just like Paul was after he was stoned to death.
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 02:11 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by thirddan
i dont understand why you just repeated my post...
It may seem like i did.

Quote:
seems like millions of people are put into situations where self defense if important...
Quote:
It's more like millions of people are put into situations where self defense seems important.
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 02:12 PM
Wouldn't hell or exterminating people to keep heaven perfect be considered killing in self defense. If not then i would think the killings by Jesus in Revelations would be looked at that way.
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 02:14 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gunth0807
It may seem like i did.
ah, i missed that...
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 02:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by batair
Wouldn't hell or exterminating people to keep heaven perfect be considered killing in self defense. If not then i would think the killings by Jesus in Revelations would be looked at that way.
If i kill someone in self defense, how would that be keeping Heaven perfect? Are people judged acceptable to Heaven according to if i kill them or not? (Hint. Not even close.)
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 02:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gunth0807
If i kill someone in self defense, how would that be keeping Heaven perfect? Are people judged acceptable to Heaven according to if i kill them or not? (Hint. Not even close.)
You missed the seconded part. According to some Jesus will kill his enemies in an end-times battle. So if you want to kill people in self defensive just join up with Jesus in the great Armageddon and you can kill all the non believers you want.
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 02:30 PM
Just ask the guy if he's a Christian and accepts the Lord Jesus Christ as his Savior. If he's about to do you bodily harm, he's probably in no mood. So when he laughs or says no, you can assume he's a heretic and it's okay to kill him.
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 03:06 PM
Good, another reason to not be a Christian. I of course value my life more than everyone else in the world and I wouldn't hesitate to kill someone in self defense if I had a gun or knife.
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 03:14 PM
Its inconceivable that organized Chrisitianity does not have an official stance/argument explaining why it is OK for them to kill to avoid being murdered.
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 03:18 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Financier
Good, another reason to not be a Christian. I of course value my life more than everyone else in the world and I wouldn't hesitate to kill someone in self defense if I had a gun or knife.
Do you not see that is one of the main problem with man? Most everyone values their life over others, and people suffer as a result.

Almost every problem known to man is a result of this. (If not every single one)

That is why we are given a Golden Rule to follow.

Last edited by Gunth0807; 06-11-2010 at 03:28 PM.
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 03:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by David Sklansky
Its inconceivable that organized Chrisitianity does not have an official stance/argument explaining why it is OK for them to kill to avoid being murdered.
Probably because there is nothing in God's Word for them to back up such a stance.
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 03:33 PM
"Love your neighbor as yourself."

Letting someone live who wants to murder you is, in most circumstances, loving your neighbor more than yourself, which is contrary to God's word.
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 03:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gunth0807
I agree that is the default assumption (for most people), but for Christians, it should not be.
Are you saying that you would not fight to defend your country? Would you be a conscientious objector?

I want to say that Christians make up a huge percentage of the US military, but I could be wrong. Don't think so, but could be. Haven't looked it up.
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 04:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lestat
Are you saying that you would not fight to defend your country? Would you be a conscientious objector?

I want to say that Christians make up a huge percentage of the US military, but I could be wrong. Don't think so, but could be. Haven't looked it up.
I cannot kill another man. If someone wants to come into our country and slaughter me because of their own personal interests, then that is their choice and they will be judged by that action. I personally think Christians are tricked into joining the military.
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote
06-11-2010 , 04:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gunth0807
I cannot kill another man. If someone wants to come into our country and slaughter me because of their own personal interests, then that is their choice and they will be judged by that action. I personally think Christians are tricked into joining the military.
You are talking in terms of you only. Do you have any children, family, or other loved ones? Would you be willing to let an intruder rape, murder, or torture them if you could stop it by killing him?

And where do you draw the line? So you won't kill, but would you at least be willing to fight to prevent the torture or murder of a loved one? Or would you turn the other cheek and watch your daughter or mother be raped?

I think it's admirable that you don't want to kill (or fight), but I want to make sure that you've thought about this deeply enough. Are you saying that if you saw someone gunning down a classroom full of kindergartners, you would not be willing to take a life to save those kids? What about someone who is about to blow up a stadium full of 40,000 innocent people? How about 250,000? What if all you had to do was punch him in the nose?
Killing a Man in Self Defence Quote

      
m