Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Heaven and Hell: If you were god... Heaven and Hell: If you were god...

03-03-2009 , 07:56 AM
I think I would be fairly horrible.

I remember when I played simcity, you always built it up good...but c'mon...when you were "done" you started cheat mode and poured down disaster and had a blast.

Nobody (or atleast very few people) would play a strategy game that was about being as nice as possible. Havoc, violence, doom, punishment, revenge, winning...yeah!
Heaven and Hell: If you were god... Quote
03-03-2009 , 10:00 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by tame_deuces
I think I would be fairly horrible.

I remember when I played simcity, you always built it up good...but c'mon...when you were "done" you started cheat mode and poured down disaster and had a blast.

Nobody (or atleast very few people) would play a strategy game that was about being as nice as possible. Havoc, violence, doom, punishment, revenge, winning...yeah!
lol. So true
Heaven and Hell: If you were god... Quote
03-03-2009 , 11:15 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hardball47
It's just if you believe that there will definitely be eternal suffering if you willingly - the caveat - indulge in a lifetime of "sin." If you don't believe... Well, obviously applying the idea of justice here would be trivial.

Imagine you're driving down a road on a long trip. You come to a split and see me sitting on a bench, reading the paper, having a sandwich and generally minding my own business. You're lost and your map is somewhat outdated, so you decide to come and ask for directions. I tell you that both of these roads lead to your destination. One of them is a very short trip (50-60 minutes), while the other will take you at least five hours. I caution you that the shortcut, however, has poor terrain (you have a small, four-door coup) and no pit stops (food, gas, restroom), so chances are good that very few others might take this path.

You don't have a particular time-frame for this trip, but you decide to go the shortcut anyway. It's a very bumpy ride with lots of potholes and jagged rocks. About 20 minutes down this path you blow, not one, but two of your tires ("well, ****..."). You pull out your phone to call for roadside assistance from AAA, but there's just one HUGE problem: no reception. You're ****ed now, and the wife is going into hyper nag mode (oh yeah, you have a wife that loves to nag, btw).

Would you believe everything (anything) I told you before you took the road? Would you ever assume I was lying, or consider the possibility that I might be deceiving you? For what purpose (aside from the tiny, outside possibility that I may derive sadistic pleasure from misleading naive travelers)? Why? Would you be correct in thinking something like, "why the **** didn't that ***-**** tell me this was going to happen" post facto?
i have no idea what the hell ^this^ is

are you saying yes to my question? jesus christ
Heaven and Hell: If you were god... Quote
03-03-2009 , 01:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by nittyit
I already know the response... in his opinion there is no eternal torment or hell... you simply cease to exist or you die the "second death". He will reference Greg Boyd and his take on hell but even Boyd's view doesn't agree with Jib. Boyd believes in a purgatory like state and Jib doesn't believe in purgatory.
Boyd does not believe in purgatory. The refining fire that he talks about is not purgatory. He even makes mention not to confuse the two, iirc.

And I would not make any certain statement on his theology based on that one sentence, that I must admit confused me.

But no, I do not believe that hell is eternal.
Heaven and Hell: If you were god... Quote
03-03-2009 , 04:07 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
Boyd does not believe in purgatory. The refining fire that he talks about is not purgatory. He even makes mention not to confuse the two, iirc.

And I would not make any certain statement on his theology based on that one sentence, that I must admit confused me.

But no, I do not believe that hell is eternal.
fine, fair enough.

lets go the other way with it then. is an eternity of bliss in heaven a just reward for believing in Christ?
Heaven and Hell: If you were god... Quote
03-03-2009 , 04:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by dragonystic
fine, fair enough.

lets go the other way with it then. is an eternity of bliss in heaven a just reward for believing in Christ?
I would not say that heaven is a reward. More so a gift. And this gift is extended to everyone equally.

So the idea that anyone is worthy is negligible.
Heaven and Hell: If you were god... Quote
03-03-2009 , 05:56 PM
srsly hardball what was that
Heaven and Hell: If you were god... Quote
03-03-2009 , 06:38 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
I would not say that heaven is a reward. More so a gift. And this gift is extended to everyone equally.

So the idea that anyone is worthy is negligible.
fine. is it a just *gift* for believing in Christ? yes or no

edit: you seem to be saying no, we dont deserve it, but he gives us this gift anyways. so how is that a just god, giving us more than we deserve?

Last edited by dragonystic; 03-03-2009 at 06:46 PM.
Heaven and Hell: If you were god... Quote
03-03-2009 , 07:30 PM
Apparently, It's every bit as reasonable to assume Hardball has the same level of knowledge about heaven and hell that you would expect a local to have about road conditions.
Heaven and Hell: If you were god... Quote
03-04-2009 , 01:55 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bulletproof Monk
srsly hardball what was that
It's just food for thought. Don't upchuck, if it's too much.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Silent A
Apparently, It's every bit as reasonable to assume Hardball has the same level of knowledge about heaven and hell that you would expect a local to have about road conditions.
LOL I see you're putting your PhD to some use, assuming what's written in your location is true.

I'm not a religious scholar, so I will state the obvious: If you want information about heaven/hell and what they would be like, as well as their entry requirements, scour the holy texts of the world's major religions and draw your own personal conclusions, but only after consulting with the respective authority of the religious description you're interpreting.

The less knowledge one generally has, the quicker they will tend to conclude on a particular matter. This is just the natural process. The more and more information you have available, the more reluctant you will be in coming to a conclusion.
Heaven and Hell: If you were god... Quote
03-04-2009 , 08:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hardball47
I'm not a religious scholar, so I will state the obvious: If you want information about heaven/hell and what they would be like, as well as their entry requirements, scour the holy texts of the world's major religions and draw your own personal conclusions, but only after consulting with the respective authority of the religious description you're interpreting.
If you wanted information on how astrology works you'd probably collect all the works from noted astrology experts in order to figure out exactly how it is that the way the stars are aligned when you are born effect your entire life. You'd of course be sure to consult with astrology experts to make sure your interpretations are correct.

If you did that would you expect to find anything with any truth value? What makes you think information about heaven and hell would be any different?
Heaven and Hell: If you were god... Quote
03-04-2009 , 08:50 PM
Quote:
It's just food for thought. Don't upchuck, if it's too much.
i seriously havent understood what you have been trying to say in a single post in this thread so far
Heaven and Hell: If you were god... Quote
03-05-2009 , 01:35 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Justin A
If you did that would you expect to find anything with any truth value? What makes you think information about heaven and hell would be any different?
Astrology is not a religion, and has no information on a heaven or a hell. Also, I said "information", not "truth." You probably didn't properly read what I said. I don't see what your issue is.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bulletproof Monk
i seriously havent understood what you have been trying to say in a single post in this thread so far
It's OK, don't worry too much about it; it's not a big deal.
Heaven and Hell: If you were god... Quote
03-05-2009 , 02:47 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by thirddan
If you were the omnipotent and omniscient creator of the universe...
-would you have created a heaven and a hell?
-What would they be like?
-Would they be eternal or would it be possible to go from hell to heaven eventually?
-What would the criteria for entry to either place be?
I guess I'll take a stab at this. You're missing an essential question though - "If you were the creator of the universe, would you give people souls (in this case, defining the soul as a piece of being that persists after death of the body)?

If you did, what do you then do with the souls?

But, let's see.

Say I'm God. Then I make a place that's perfect. Totally, pristinely, for-all-time perfect.

Then, I put some humans down somewhere else. Somewhere I've made perfect, but then the humans screw it all up.

Then, they die. Think I'm letting them into my perfect place, when I gave them their own perfect place and they messed it up?

Hell (literally) no. No way I'm damaging my perfect dwelling for all time.

So that's my answer: If you want to hang out in the perfect place, be perfect, or gtfo.
Heaven and Hell: If you were god... Quote
03-05-2009 , 07:55 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
And this gift is extended to everyone equally.
I don't think this is true.

Isolating this premise and ignoring its implications (and assuming Chirstianity true), some people are born and indoctrinated Christian and basically guaranteed salvation while many are born and indoctrinated to an opposing theology and have close to no chance of salvation, and then there are those that live their entire lives without ever hearing of Christ.

Looks like some people are more equal than others.

Can you defend the position that everyone is given an equal chance of salvation?
Heaven and Hell: If you were god... Quote
03-05-2009 , 12:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by starvingwriter82
I guess I'll take a stab at this. You're missing an essential question though - "If you were the creator of the universe, would you give people souls (in this case, defining the soul as a piece of being that persists after death of the body)?

If you did, what do you then do with the souls?

But, let's see.

Say I'm God. Then I make a place that's perfect. Totally, pristinely, for-all-time perfect.

Then, I put some humans down somewhere else. Somewhere I've made perfect, but then the humans screw it all up.

Then, they die. Think I'm letting them into my perfect place, when I gave them their own perfect place and they messed it up?

Hell (literally) no. No way I'm damaging my perfect dwelling for all time.

So that's my answer: If you want to hang out in the perfect place, be perfect, or gtfo.
But you're God, so you knew it all would happen like it did, but you chose to create the way you did anyway.
Heaven and Hell: If you were god... Quote

      
m