Quote:
Originally Posted by Mightyboosh
I'd agree that would be annoying if that's what I was doing but it's not. "Young Earth Creationists" are just one of many many examples of how religion hinders our search for understanding. <snip>
My point is that, within Christianity, they are something of an extreme of this kind of problem. E.g. YECs are in the subset of Christians that are Biblical inerrantists and in the further subset of Biblical inerrantists who are Biblical literalists. You show a marked lack of knowledge about the range of Christian thought that exists.
As an example, there was an Ipso-MORI poll done on UK people who had ticked the box marked "Christian" in the last census. From that data we can look at some of your common claims and arguments:
(All participants are self-identifying Christians)
46% of Christians gave the main reason for considering themselves Christians as "I was christened/baptised into this religion" and 13% as "One or both of my parents are/were members of this religion". Only 18% gave "I believe in the teachings of this religion" as the main reason for their religious identity.
This suggests that a majority of self-identifying Christians are already well-aware that Childhood Indoctrination© is the primary reason for their religious beliefs, undermining your argument that pointing this fact out is likely to make the foundations of their faith crumble into dust.
But you do also argue that the range of religious faiths that exist should give Christians pause to consider that their faith is likely to be wrong. Unfortunately, the top answer (37%) to the question "Which of the following statements best describes YOUR personal view of God? " was "I believe in God and I believe that Christianity is just one way of knowing him". A further 23% advocate for some form of vague pantheism/deism. So again, it seems a majority of UK Christians are not very dogmatic about their faith and your argument is likely to fall flat as a consequence.
Moving on to your arguments that Christians are forcing children to be indoctrinated into Christianity, a majority (57%) of Christians state that there views on Religious Education are best summarised as "Teach knowledge about the world’s main faiths even-handedly, without any bias towards any particular religion". On the subject of the Daily Act of Worship, opinion is fairly evenly split between those who support (39%) and those who oppose (36%).
The point of all this is to show you that, even among Christians, there is a broad range of thought on every issue and just because the most dogmatic voices are the loudest doesn't mean those voices accurately reflect the broad trends within the population. Having a one-size-fits-all approach to debating religion is not going to be effective.
And do read the whole survey, it's quite eye-opening.