Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Asking the Father for his spirit Asking the Father for his spirit

09-11-2024 , 05:34 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by craig1120
The truth and meaning we need is hidden in the irrational and unintelligible. Consult the deepest level of your conscience for confirmation.
An example of such « universal » truth you found with that method ?
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-11-2024 , 04:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Montrealcorp
An example of such « universal » truth you found with that method ?
Don’t feed the troll. We had reached a nirvana where he was the only one responding to his posts.
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-11-2024 , 04:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by DesertCat
Don’t feed the troll. We had reached a nirvana where he was the only one responding to his posts.
Well no doubt you are the mvp of this thread but let’s see if he can provide any “evidences” to support his claims of “real truth”.
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-11-2024 , 04:42 PM
Getting the best of me on this forum doesn’t stop the serpent from continuing to bite your heels.
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-11-2024 , 04:54 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by DesertCat
Don’t feed the troll. We had reached a nirvana where he was the only one responding to his posts.
He's not trolling.
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-11-2024 , 04:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gregory Illinivich
He's not trolling.
He is not answering either as always when ask anything tangible ….
Pretty close to trolling ain’t it ?
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-11-2024 , 05:13 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Montrealcorp
He is not answering either as always when ask anything tangible ….
Pretty close to trolling ain’t it ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by craig1120
We are all given seeds of remembering who we are: falling in love, moments of awe and wonder, witnessing greatness, unexpected kindness, synchronicities, testimonies, brushes with death, art, etc.

What happens with the seeds varies, as Jesus explained in the parable. These seeds of remembering will be the only form of evidence provided to you.
Trolling is more like demanding an answer to a question which the person has already addressed in that very same thread.
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-11-2024 , 05:55 PM
Quote:

The kingdom of heaven is like treasure hidden in a field. When a man found it, he hid it again, and then in his joy went and sold all he had and bought that field.
Understand what Jesus is teaching you to do about these seeds of remembering. The hidden treasure is associated with these seeds. The field is your inner world. To sell all you have is to detach from the counterfeit meaning associated with your external world.

After you’ve done this, then you become inwardly focused on caring for these seeds so that they grow and bear fruit.
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-11-2024 , 10:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by craig1120
Trolling is more like demanding an answer to a question which the person has already addressed in that very same thread.
Again, something that means nothing and can’t be proven .
Just an unfounded idea that you like .
There is absolutely no universal proofs of what u just said , at all .

But it’s ok .
It’s the game u play .
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-11-2024 , 10:26 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Montrealcorp
Again, something that means nothing and can’t be proven .
Just an unfounded idea that you like .
There is absolutely no universal proofs of what u just said , at all .

But it’s ok .
It’s the game u play .
But you're the one asking for « universal » truth. Craig didn't suggest universality, nor did he make any claims that conflict with physical reality as we understand it. You guys are on different planes. He's talking about the inner life; the soul; one's heart of hearts. If you're asking for demonstrable evidence of God or for him to justify his faith in an objective and purely rational way, you're asking the wrong questions.
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-11-2024 , 10:48 PM
Earlier in this thread, you responded how convenient it was when I suggested that there may be serval paths leading to the Divine, but it's a position I've held for quite some time. Think of a moral belief that you have. At a certain point, you're going to hit a wall where the justification for that belief relies on your own subjectivity, and you won't be able to justify it with rationalism. The logical starting point then—is subjectivity.
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-11-2024 , 11:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Montrealcorp
Again, something that means nothing and can’t be proven .
Just an unfounded idea that you like .
There is absolutely no universal proofs of what u just said , at all .

But it’s ok .
It’s the game u play .
What do you value most? Do you ever consciously contemplate what you want to value most?
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-11-2024 , 11:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by craig1120
What do you value most? Do you ever consciously contemplate what you want to value most?
A long time ago, when I did this, I determined that I wanted to value meaning most because I wanted more meaning in my life.

Once I committed to this and consciously held the desire for more meaning, then rational truth was no longer sufficient. Without this overlapping experience, then none of what I talk about on this subforum will land with you. I view this desire for more meaning as universal in adults, but it gets suppressed.

When you decide to value meaning most, then meaning becomes associated with truth and rational / empirical / scientific truth becomes a lower level truth.
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-11-2024 , 11:46 PM
Ultimately, the fundamental disagreement is over which should be valued highest - rational truth or meaning?
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-12-2024 , 12:19 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by craig1120
Ultimately, the fundamental disagreement is over which should be valued highest - rational truth or meaning?
Yeah, and a disconnect when it comes to the conception of God and the nature of religion.
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-12-2024 , 12:43 AM
Rational truth is associated with the head and with propositions.

The truth of meaning is associated with the body, with the self, and with narrative / symbols.

Rational truth is associated with the known and the comfort zone. Meaning is associated with the chaotic unknown and the hero’s journey.
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-12-2024 , 01:24 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by craig1120
Rational truth is associated with the head and with propositions.

The truth of meaning is associated with the body, with the self, and with narrative / symbols.

Rational truth is associated with the known and the comfort zone. Meaning is associated with the chaotic unknown and the hero’s journey.
This reminded of an answer that Jordan Peterson gave during the Q&A section of his debate with Matt Dillahunty. They were asked to explain, respectively, why the language and values of secular humanism and religion were better than the other. Peterson's response was illuminating. There's a lot that could be expanded on, but given that this was live, it was a really good answer.

Quote:
Religious propositions are in some sense abstracted generalizations about what being consists of and how to act in it. It's not the same thing as a set of hypotheses about material reality, and it's partly because in the religious domain the moral imperative is primary, whereas in the empirical domain the factual is primary; the sensory is primary. It's something like that. So the question from the religious perspective is something like: how should we best construe the world if we wish to determine how to act properly within it? And the way that that language has developed—it's developed as a consequence of an evolutionary process, both biological and cultural, and it's culminated in a set of stories, essentially, that have characters. The characters basically represent something like the permanently unknowable. So that's the mystery that surrounds us all, and that would be associated with the potential of the future and the potential in you; the part of being that's transcendent; that constantly escapes from your theorizing. That's the unknown. It's like unexplored territory for animals, and it's a permanent part of being.

So, there's unexplored territory: the unknown. And there's explored territory: culture; the known. And that's this room, and that's the culture mores that unite us well enough so that we can all sit here and be peaceful while we're discussing difficult things. So that's the landscape; the religions landscape. That's yin and yang. That's chaos and order. Interestingly enough, it looks like it's to that landscape that our brain has adapted, because the right hemisphere looks like it's roughly responsible for processing chaos on the unknown and the left hemisphere roughly responsible for processing the known and the familiar...

And so that's the religious domain: yin and yang; chaos and order, and it places human beings at the center of that. The idea is that we're always confronted by what we understand and have to adapt to that even in its tyrannical manifestation, and we're always faced with the permanent reality of the permanently incomprehensible that can burst into our life at any moment and disrupt it. That's reality. And then the religious question is: if that's reality, how do you orient yourself in relationship to those two permanent domains? And the answer to that is something like: pursue the instinct of meaning—because it looks like meaning is the instinctive response, neuropsychologically grounded in the orienting reflect, I would say, which is a very primordial reflex for the unknown—meaning is the response that orients us in that world—and so when we're engaged in a meaningful enterprise it's a signal from the deepest elements of our biological being that we have the balance between what we know and makes us secure and what we don't know and have yet to explore, properly sync. And that makes us secure but not totalitarian, and engaged but not terrified.

And by staying on that midpoint; that midpoint of balance—that's Tao, by the way. That's the Way from the Taoist perspective—by staying on that midpoint we do what's best for us, what's best for our families, what's best for our community, and God only knows beyond that. We do all of that simultaneously. And we can tell when we're doing that. It speaks to us when we're doing that. And that's the deepest of religious instincts, and it's that capability to orient on that border between chaos and order that's exemplified in great mythological heroes like Saint George who goes out to slay the dragon. Or Christ, who welcomes death; who embraces mortality and vulnerability and strives forward nonetheless. And there's nothing outside of the religious language that communicates that kind of grandeur. There's nothing that you could use to communicate to people who are in the direst of straits what's most important about life in the manner that will help set them straight and put their soul at peace. So that's the advantage of the religious language.
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-12-2024 , 01:24 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gregory Illinivich
Yeah, and a disconnect when it comes to the conception of God and the nature of religion.
The discussion gets further confused because theists are mostly rationalists as well in how they (consciously) view truth. At least the theists who are having discussions are.
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-12-2024 , 01:46 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by craig1120
The discussion gets further confused because theists are mostly rationalists as well in how they (consciously) view truth. At least the theists who are having discussions are.
This is a good point. It's difficult to converse with atheists/rationalists because they often make their arguments based on preconceived notions about religion that come from preachers a la Joel Osteen and Pat Robertson. Even more philosophical theists like William Lane Craig and Bishop Barron often fall into that category.
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-12-2024 , 01:50 AM
As Peterson mentions, the truth of meaning is associated with action. Trial and error through the maze. I would want to challenge the idea of staying on the midpoint, but it’s a helpful entry level idea.
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-12-2024 , 01:59 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by craig1120
As Peterson mentions, the truth of meaning is associated with action. Trial and error through the maze. I would want to challenge the idea of staying on the midpoint, but it’s a helpful entry level idea.
How so? I don't know a ton about Taoism, but from a Catholic perspective, it seems like that midpoint could be associated with the Holy Spirit. When one's life story comes into alignment with religious truth and God, that's when they feel the presence of the Holy Spirit. To quote Belinda Carlisle, "Ooh, Heaven is a place on Earth."
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-12-2024 , 02:16 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gregory Illinivich
How so? I don't know a ton about Taoism, but from a Catholic perspective, it seems like that midpoint could be associated with the Holy Spirit. When one's life story comes into alignment with religious truth and God, that's when they feel the presence of the Holy Spirit. To quote Belinda Carlisle, "Ooh, Heaven is a place on Earth."
Once the truth seeker values meaning highest and identifies with it, then he must sacrifice it up (sell off his possessions) and fall into nihilism (meaninglessness, chaos).

The HS wants to stretch and test your faith. It wants your full trust.

Imagine being in a dark forest and the HS is calling you further out from your illuminated home (comfort zone). The HS will keep drawing you out until you can no longer see the light.

The Christian story is far more extreme and radical than the eastern religions. In the parable, Jesus describes the son as lost and dead because that is what the HS requires of us. The Christian story, which is the story of reality, is very dramatic.
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-12-2024 , 02:35 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by craig1120
The Christian story, which is the story of reality, is very dramatic.
What was reality in the 300,000 years of human history before Jesus and the Holy Spirit came?
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-12-2024 , 02:55 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by FellaGaga-52
What was reality in the 300,000 years of human history before Jesus and the Holy Spirit came?
Do you think I don’t have an answer for this? Have you considered the scenario where you stump, expose, and humiliate me is solely a fantasy in your mind?

I answered this question on July 21st, but I’m not going to link the post because you’re not actually seeking wisdom.
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote
09-12-2024 , 12:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by craig1120
The discussion gets further confused because theists are mostly rationalists as well in how they (consciously) view truth. At least the theists who are having discussions are.
The Holy Spirit / conscience is anti-status-quo. As a default, your survival instinct will suppress the HS and rationalize on behalf of the status quo. If you’re a Christian, and you hold the same beliefs + live the same life for years, then my criticisms of rationalism apply to you too.
Asking the Father for his spirit Quote

      
m