Quote:
No. You are suggesting as your premise that in order to have valid spiritual advice, a person must be Christian. That is akin to suggesting that in order to have valid nutritional advice, one must follow a no-carb diet.
No. I am suggesting that in order for spiritual advice to a christian to be taken seriously, it must come from a Christian. And I do not mean that to be a hard and fast rule, but that I am less likely, and should be, to listen to much of what a non-christian says on matters of christianity then what a christian says.
Quote:
There is no "Christian spirituality," spirituality is spirituality. And there's no such thing as "no-carb nutrition," nutrition is nutrition. Some nutritionists advocate low carb diets, just as some spiritualists advocate the tenets of Christianity, but you can't take the recommendation of an expert as the criterion for expertise.
I would say that your first line is, to a christian at least, obviously false. Which is exactly why I would not lend much validity to what a non-Christian has to say about matters of Christianity.
If you and I disagreed on every aspect of morality, would you still take advise about morality from me?
Quote:
You can't argue that Christianity enhances spirituality because spiritual experts say it does, and then define a spiritual expert as someone who believes that Christianity enhances spirituality. It's circular and fallacious.
That is only if I believe that christian spirituality was exactly the same as other forms of spirituality. Which is a statement that I never said. Hence none of your analogies thus far have been accurate.
Quote:
Non-Christian spiritualists put plenty of value behind "Christian spirituality," they simply don't describe it as "Christian" spirituality. The two are completely unrelated.
Again, from a Christian perspective this is just a false statement.
Quote:
The fact that I do "non-Christian pushups" doesn't mean that I put no validity behind "Christian pushups." People who do lots of pushups will get better at doing pushups, it doesn't matter whether they are Christians, Buddhists, or atheists.
Now you are just attacking strawmen. The ideal of spirituality is absolutely nothing like pushups. If you want to analogies lets look at something that makes sense like my morals analogy.
Quote:
Same goes for meditation, development of loving-kindness, and connection with the source. The question of what that source is doesn't factor into it.
And yet again, as a Christian this statement could not be more false. Which is once again why I would not put much steak in the advice of a non-Christian on the matters of spirituality.