Quote:
Originally Posted by groton
I'd not call the floor why? He could be teaching her the game I see nothing wrong with this.
How did you learn how to play poker? Unless your answer is "I learned by sitting behind my boyfriend and looking at his hole cards as he played a session" then it should be clear that there are other ways to learn poker and other ways to teach it.
That said, i should clarify its not like im going to call the floor over the first time he shows his cards to her. I would obv ask him not to do it first.
Quote:
Originally Posted by eco74
Who's the other player?
Showing the hand to the girlfriend = fine, go ahead
Having GF give advice or commentary on the hand = call the floor
You are correct. RROP does allow you to have a guest sit behind you and does allow you to show that guest your hand. This is easily the stupidest rule in rrop, and i can't imagine a rational justification for it.
However, the rule is qualified with the requirement that no one at the table objects. I will always object if hes showing cards.
It is not violative of OPTAH in and of itself. However:
1. Showing something to someone is the first step to talking about it. Once they talk about it, its too late. The floor isnt going to do anything except say "don't do it again", probably six or seven times before he even considers taking action. -- Also, i don't want to have to monitor him/her during every hand were in together.
2. Players can get reads off her. This can act to my detriment in a MW pot with him and another player, even if she doesnt say a word.
3. Because of her position behind players backs, she is in a much better spot to be able to spot other players cards or even front load the dealer. This is bad enough, and one of the reasons spectators sitting behind the players makes me uncomfortable to begin with. When youre adding to that her being able to know what his hand is in addition its just too much for me. Basically we play our hands at the table because everything is set up so that we cant easily get info we're not supposed to have -- so to my way of thinking the flow of information should be restricted to the players sitting at the table.
so by allowing this youre setting up an optah vioaltion that you can't remedy and youre making it much easier for people to cheat if they are so inclined. In exchange, youre gaining precisely nothing for the game aside from allowing a douchenozzle in a ed hardy shirt to feel more at home.
Last edited by Turyia; 02-10-2014 at 11:58 AM.