Quote:
Originally Posted by Steve00007
I just don’t get why you come in here complaining about hate when you hate on a guy because “he only won 3.” Must be a nice problem to have when your team is that successful.
Also, have you seen the criticism that Marle and TBC get? It’s not just one guy getting criticized. People criticized Bike King too.
2009 Worst save percentage of any Cup winning goalie=team in front of him won the Cup despite his "efforts".
2016 Benched for the Cup run, Murray's performance steals it for us.
2017 Now backing up Murray, as he should have been, but playing with Murray hurt manages to "only" give up 15 goals in the Columbus series, but posts the win, thanks for that. Gives up "only" 18 goals in the Caps series as the Pens manage to win the games he doesn't get us blown out in and survive the series.
Signs of MAF life after two game (which the Pens split) against Ottawa including a shutout in game 2! He backs that up by getting pulled in game 3 after surrendering 4 goals on 9 shots. Playoff MAF is back. Murray gets the net back and gives up only 5 goals in 5 games. Pens win Cup and while MAF didn't kill us, he certainly tried.
Not sure whyy you support him so, but if you want to talk about the non Cup years where he gives up 30 goals in 6 games to the Flyers then we probably should start our own thread and not derail this one further.
TLDR: Pens would have had a dynasty in not for dragging that anchor along with them. Give us a decent goalie and the Pens win 5 Cups minimum in that window. Maybe more.
MAF will never win another Cup. Mediocre goalie who had the benefit of generational talent in front of him.