Quote:
Originally Posted by ZeeJustin
If the criteria is "best Italian" (specifying because overall I like Carnevino better than B&B for example):
Bartalotta > B&B > Carnevino > Circo > Valentino > Sirio > Mortarano's
Bartalotta is mostly seafood, (most of which is from the Mediterranean, prepared in an Italian style), so you could argue that it's not what most people refer to when they casually say "Italian food".
B&B of course has a very traditional menu that seems exotic to most Americans. It's not Americanized at all as far as I can tell.
Prob forgetting a few, but it's late and I gotta go to sleeeeep.
I've never been to Nove Italiano btw, but am somewhat excited to try it now that I see it on the top 50.
Bartolotta really is that good. It might be my favorite restaurant in Vegas. Robuchon and Guy Savoy are more dramatic and awe inspiring, but if I want to spend less than 4 hours on a meal, Bartolotta is my #1.
Agree with all of this, except for the inclusion of Martorano on a list of best Italian places, even at the very bottom.
Martorano might be the worst food, of any variety, that I've ever paid more than 30 dollars to eat.
I would for sure go to Enoteca San Marco, The Pasta Shop, cheap Italian delis like Cugino's or Rocco's, Rao's, or even a crappy chain like Maggiano's, over Martorano. Even if the food were tolerable, the giant monitors showing clips from gangster movies alternated with blaring top 40 music and
actual ****ing disco balls and strobe lights would make going to Martorano a miserable experience.
edit: My girlfriend just saw this post and reminded me about a meal we had at Ferraro's on Flamingo. It cost more than $30 per person and was even worse than Martorano. They also had a magician performing during dinner, followed by a lounge singer who couldn't hit a note
Last edited by ike; 11-23-2010 at 11:08 AM.