Bloo, we liked the croquetas also:
Wine was i guess fine but not good. Not sure what we expected for $36 but he just said we should definitely go with that for a tempranillo. If their other tempranillos are worse god help them.
Amuse: was great. watermelon and mint gazpacho
Oysters: the oysters were really good. I didn't think any of the accompaniments added anything though - would order plain.
La Lata: roasted red peppers and anchovies served on toast points. Was fine. There was one uni-stuffed olive on this plate that was really good but out of nowhere
Fermented tomato salad: Very good. Would recommend.
Lobster salpicon: This dish was good also. Big chunks of lobster in kind of a ceviche preparation. Was looking for a little more from the salsa but overall still solid.
Tortilla de patatas: Pedestrian, but no real complaints. It's a simple dish, and they prepared it in an authentic way
Buñuelo de bacalao: Cod fritters. They were black all the way through and looked like little charcoal briquettes (squid ink). These were a little overfried imho, and the squid ink didn't add anything to the dish but it made these visually unappealing
Clams: Ok, so this was pretty weird. It was clams in a beef and lemon broth, with maybe a lemon verbena or something lemony and herbal in the broth. The beef and lemon broth was v good, but then you got these big pieces of herb and it was pretty bitter lemon and just overwhelming. And the clams had no real taste, crushed by the broth.
Pulpo: Octopus was cooked perfectly but served with an incredibly strong, thick tamarind mole -- really a paste, not a sauce. This could be a taste thing, but I thought the tamarind mole was -- not gross, but really unappealing. Octopus isnt really strong so i think it needs something really light to accompany it. Was another one where we were left scratching our heads.
Pan Amb Tomaquet: Really fantastic, but again it's such a simple dish -- tomato on bread -- that you don't get a lot of points for getting it right (of course its a huge minus if you screw it up. Totally unfair but i make my scoring rubric :shrug
Croquetas: Lots going on, and a really creamy(?) almost liquidy filling. Perfect little fritters just oozing a gooey taste bomb filling. I dont even remember what was inside but i know it was good
Patatas bravas: Usually double fried little potato cubes served with chili sauce and 'alioli' - a garlicky aioli. These things are addictive. The EDO potatoes are awesome but their sauce leaves a lot to be desired. Imagine four 1" x 1" x 6" sticks each consisting of 6-10 layers of long potato slices, fried what seems like it must be seventeen (but probably is 2) times. It was a french fry, but instead of a piece of potato, you had all these great layers. Great mix of crispy and soft. Friends said theirs were *really* greasy but ours were really great. Again, really wanted that garlic sauce though. They gave a "spicy alioli" but the fun w bravas is you can make them really spicy or really garlicky/creamy. Overall the dish missed even though the potatoes were god damn heavenly.
Then there was the service. I don't know if I'll remember all the things but:
1) Your wait staff should be able to pronounce your dishes, or at least not try and totally botch it. It was comical. Poor kid clearly took french or german in high school or something.
2) Your wait staff should bring the right food (not an order of the one type of oyster we didn't order, for example)
3) One waiter took my wine glass away when it was empty and we had half a bottle of wine left. Wife and I were laughing about it and called him back over to bring a new wine glass, and I joked that i thought he was going to fill my glass up, not take it away. And he apologized for being rude but still left me an empty wine glass. No one poured wine for us all evening except the first glass.
4) Service was generally inattentive - even getting the wine glass back took a few minutes
5) There was a somm, but when we were ordering, the waiter just gave his suggestions, which were laughable. Didn't find out about somm until dessert wine.
6) The bravas we ordered never came out. The waiter came back and asked if we wanted the check (not dessert or anything) and i told him we wanted the bravas we ordered that never came out. No apology, nothing. Just bravas.
7) Table next to us: woman never got her drink, food came out wrong, they paid and left halfway through their meal. The tables on the wall are a little tight, so we got to be a part of their service issues too.
Think that might be it.