Quote:
Originally Posted by bulldawgblue
Ok....I'm not digging the Yelp reviews for Bartalotta. I'm going to be pissed if I pay 300 for a crappy meal...I need help LVers! Where should I go for an awesome seafood dinner this March?
Quote:
Originally Posted by StevieG
Uh, do you trust yelpers more than 2p2ers?
There has been (as far as I recall) only positive remarks in this thread for Bartolotta.
If there is something in particular about the yelp reviews, you should specify, people here may have something to add.
There are other places, for sure. RM Seafood in Mandalay Bay offers two levels of dining (a more formal room upstairs, and a more casual place downstairs). The downstairs has good seafood prepared well, and you are more likely to spend $150 for two with wine, maybe some oysters, etc.
But the Bartolotta experience was great, and worth the money.
I read through the Yelp reviews and a whole lot of the negative ones seemed to be people who were appalled to be charged so much for fish (look at a ****ing menu or call the restaurant before you show up, moron) and couldn't remember precisely what they'd eaten or had shown up with an 18 person bachelorette party and ordered the chicken. By contrast, the positive reviews were by people who knew what they were going to the restaurant for, had had similar things before, and reported that Bartolotta was superlatively good at what they do. To be fair there were a few reports of really bad service. Such things happen every once in a while nearly everywhere and are particularly likely to end up on Yelp when they do. In my 4 or so trips there, the service has been fantastic every time, but for all I know it might be more variable than at other comparably priced places.
If they have it when you go, or I suppose if you encounter it someplace else, get the slipper lobster. The waiter described it to us by saying that it was a small species of lobster which ate other crustaceans, causing it to develop a concentrated crustacean flavor. It was the richest, most flavorful lobster I've ever eaten, almost like another creature entirely.
I've been to RM a couple times, only the downstairs area, and been pretty happy with it. From what I recall, $150 is even a pretty high estimate, though I don't think I've gotten wine there. Last time I was there my gf and I split a 750ml bottle of hard cider (wish I could remember the name, it was from upstate NY iirc) that was like $25 and really really good.
American Fish (by Michael Mina) at Aria was quite good the one time I went. More expensive than RM, cheaper than Bartolotta. $50ish entrees if I remember correctly.
I'm also a big fan of Restaurant Charlie at the Palazzo. Not strictly a seafood restaurant in the same sense as the others I've mentioned, but the menu does focus on seafood and it's really, really good. A bit hard to classify the style, it's sorta fusiony with heavy Asian and French influences, but much lighter and more ingredient driven than you might expect from that description. Poke around the website
http://palazzolasvegas.com/restaurantcharlie.aspx if that appeals to you at all.
Last edited by ike; 01-20-2010 at 04:39 PM.