Originally Posted by leoslayer
shemp are u saying not the best cause he got hurt and retired early? If so i could agree. Whos to say how many jones would hav had if he didnt quit or hogan if he hadnt hit the bus?
My fav tennis player is johnny mac i wonder how many he would hav won if he hadnt quit for a while ala david duval?
You have to finish the race first then we check to see if the time is good. Wind aided no fouls/penalties
You can call whomever the GOAT. Some will agree. Some won't.
Surely there is some athlete in some sport who doesn't dominate the relevant longevity categories who you think is GOAT.
This is something some people like to argue about.