Quote:
Originally Posted by NxtWrldChamp
Well he was there 3 years ago... then he hardly played in 2010 and was injured for a lot of 2011. He's healthy now, and its pretty easy to see from his last 5 outings that he is playing his best since 09 and getting better just about every tournament. It's also not surprising that short game seems to be holding him back right now, as that was deprived some practice time I'm sure while he has been working on the swing change.
Phil missed the cut in his first event this year now he is on top of the world, crowned the Tiger slayer. Tiger's played very well in every event he's played since last November and he sucks. Haha.
You know I'm as big a fanboi as they come, but I think something is different this time. I still think (and hope) he gets back to being TW, but the last two Sunday performances are concerning.
Full swing seems fine. He's hitting it better and further than he has hit it in 10 years. The putting is something different. 3 different putters in the last 12 months (and now a new grip!), a wholesale change of his stroke, etc. Mentally something is different with his putting. Whether it's just getting old or something that changed due to last few years I don't know, but it feels like something other than "need reps." Hope I'm wrong.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ctyri
I used to be a Tiger fanboi, but what turned me off to him before the scandal was all the "almost there" crap. Its a bit of a way of saying he isn't dominating because something is just not right, but gee everyone knows he really should still be dominating if he was "there". This neglects the fact that the fields are stronger and his game is simply declining (flashes but not the consistency of his younger days), and is constant feed for the Tiger-obsessed media machine. This may be unintentional on his part, but is big part of his narcissism, imo. No other player to my knowledge (except Phil on occasions) has to give a litany of all the ways their game isn't quite "there" when they lose. Others have the humility to just lose because they can't win 'em all. The fact is, until he gets "there" again, he should shut the **** up about it, as you say. Because its quite possible he'll never be "there" again, and/or others are already there with him. If he needs a new swing every 3 years, then so be it. But stop dragging it out like a handicap everytime you lose, you're over 35 now, for ****'s sake.
First, blame a lot of that on the media. Nobody else gets asked questions about the state of his game like Tiger. Like, if [insert Tour player here] were going through a major swing change with a new coach, and was asked about his progress, it would be a completely reasonable response to say that they were getting close.
But second, there is a distinct difference between just not playing well and not playing well while working through a swing change.
Quote:
- putting is wtf bad, especially from short range. That's something that can at least be fixed on a temporary basis (ask Bernhard Langer, who has managed to win twice at Augusta despite fighting putting demons his whole career). But like a pro said once, "once you have the yips, you have the yips". It's like herpes. I haven't been paying much attention to his stroke on the short misses to see if there's something amiss there, but from memory the misses I recall have all been to the right, which is the classic righthanded player shove. Pretty sure when Phil goes off the rails and starts missing short putts most of his are to the left.
- attitude. His body language is just wtf terrible, even by the lofty standards of surliness he's set for years. Obviously a lot of this has to do with the entire modern world being made aware of his indiscretions and preference for marginally attractive women and other embarrassing details of his personal life. It's set up a sort of polarizing environment where people are either Tiger toadies who will love him no matter what or others who are disgusted or otherwise tired of it all. In short, his life isn't as fun for him as it used to be. Whether or not this bleeds into his results I don't know, but I suspect it does put pressure on him on Sundays and it shows in the results.
Agree with this for the most part.