Another personal post:
This one goes beyond what I do here. This cover some of the major issues with regard to corporal punishment in the Korean education system, among other things.
I am pretty sure I have bitched about this before, but I have great disdain for my primary co-teacher's disciplinary tactics. She hits the boys for no reason while sitting and chatting it up with the girls when they are supposed to be doing work. So, the boys must work while the girls can spend the class enjoying tea time with my co-teacher.
So, I've decided to take a similar route. Clearly, I don't hit my students and I never will do that. A good teacher should not have to resort to hitting a student except in case of self-defense which should not ever come up if you can control your class. But now, sometimes I will sit with some of the boys and hang with them. For example, two students were sent out of the class for again no real reason. Basically, their punishment is to stand outside until class was over. It was clearly an unjust punishment. Even if they did do something, it was hardly of any relevance. I took the initiative and went outside the class to chill with them under the pretense that it was hot inside the classroom (I was clearly sweating). When I got out of the classroom, I sat with them and they liked that I was there. I got some interesting questions. They asked me if they thought my co-teacher was hot. I definitely do not think so. But to maintain some balance, I said she was okay.
"Do you like her? She is not kind to me. She hits me hard."
This is the line that got to me. If there wasn't enough proof that hitting students is an ineffective means of control, that line was it. Hitting students just creates a downward spiral. You hit them and they don't like you. So, they act up. Then, you hit them harder. Then, they resist even harder and you get videos like these:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hMTXnf7mnZI
Hitting the students is completely ineffective. All it shows is two things. One, that the teacher has a lack of control of their students. Two, the teacher is on a total power trip in the classroom. The Office of Education's policy is that corporal punishment is forbidden. But that's all a front to keep outsiders quiet. Teachers here hit their students and some hit them *hard*, many times for no reason or little reason at all. The teacher in the above video got a warning. Yeah, so much for enforcing policies. Truly abhorrent.
There's a student in my school who clearly has some sort of mental disability. From my point of view, it appears that he is autistic. He will often walk up to teachers and "say" hello to them. But all he really does is nod and make some weird noise. He'll rub my upper arm and do that. I continue walking and he'll do it again. He did that while I was sleeping in between classes. It might get me a bit annoyed on occasion, but I know that he can't control it. It's just the way he is. So, I never say a word about it.
But he is not treated that way by other teachers. He is treated as though he is just another, average student when the reality is that he isn't. After my classes were over yesterday, he came in and greeted me and then did it again. I said hello back to him and wasn't really bothered. However, one of the other teachers comes by and WAP!, hits him good with a piece of wood about the size of a meter stick and forces him out of the room. It was thinner and wider. So, you'd hear a snap noise when it hit a student. He got tagged real good in the back for not knowing any better.
The reality is that the concept of mental illness is largely unknown in South Korea. It is not perceived as something to be fixed and changed. It is something to be ashamed or embarrassed about. It is often ignored or left alone until treatment is absolutely necessary. Even then, they might not get that treatment. And that treatment is normally just being locked in an insane asylum. The country is just 40-50 years behind the times when it comes to mental illness. In 2005, South Korea's suicide rate was was 26.1 persons per 100,000 which is the highest rate in the first world. The WHO estimates that 90 percent of all suicide victims had an undiagnosed mental disorder.
It is just a sordid state of affairs. The ignorance of some of these public school teachers is just astounding. Many of them have the knowledge, but have absolutely zero teaching skills what so ever. The private school has higher quality teachers. They are more intelligent, experienced, disciplined and more understanding of their students and their conditions. The more I think about it, the more different the two schools become. I think I saw a grand total of one physical attack in my entire time there. At the public school, I mean...I've lost count.