Quote:
Originally Posted by Mad1Lee
and I ask you, man (or woman), how on Earth did you come up with that bluffing range? Don't you see that's it's not even overoptimistic, it's totally unrealistic?
First of all, he has no AK/AQ there, he 3bets them. Second of all, noone ever bluffs that much. Like ever. Most of the hands you have mentioned stab the flop, some hands fold pre, some just give up. And if you assign him this ridiculous bluffing range, then include some pairs turned into bluffs too (like 65s/64s, some weird A6s/K6s) and overplayed 9x hands that we lose too.
Also, didn't notice your stack size, at 20bb your move is to shove or fold except spots where you trap with KK/AA against weaker unsuspecting players.
I don't think it's unrealistic at all. Have you played in these live sattys? This range can easily be accurate. I wouldn't be surprised to see an even wider one of A2o+ and JTo+. Agree that he three bets AK, but not necessarily AQ 100%.
You're right to worry about pairs turned to bluffs, but I don't think those are likely to snap shove river. I also agree that he should 3bet pre, but he acknowledged that, and we're discussing post. I also ask, if it's a 100% 3 bet pre if the avg stack size is 7bb's, and utg nit seems to have a range of 99+ & AK? Not that applies here, I just think it's a bit closed minded to not factor in some these things, and just make blanket, "only way to play is to do xyz" statements.
I also agree that he's not always going to bluff those hands, but does he have to, for us to profitably call? I think if we're just making good decisions, we def 3b AKs pre, we usually 3b AKo pre, but if we decide for whatever reason to flat, then the decisions post really should lead us to a call on turn and river. Of course this is very dependent on villain's range, which is where we disagree. I easily fold turn if i think villain doesn't have all of those.
Looks like I'm alone in my thinking here, but I think you were right to call turn & wouldn't fold river. Not so sure about the call pre, unless there were specific reasons to.