Quote:
Originally Posted by Soulman
Of course the factors you refer to are known. Now, please lay out how you could calculate TE's cal intake in a more useful way than the approach he himself suggested. And of course, as you know:
- Everyone follows their diet perfectly
- There is no individual variance
PS: Lyle's calculator involves inputting your gender, height, weight, activity level and BF if known.
ETA: oh noes, you're a low carb tard, aren't you?
Your posts are a bit confusing. When I said I was not an outlier and that your suggestion of "14-15kcal/lb BW" was too general, you said it wasn't pertinent to the log, but then when I said it was pertinent with citations, now you say of course those pertinent factors are known...but not relevant? So I don't get it. You disagree but then agree and skip around saying my claims are outlandish because I didn't agree with you. I feel like you, for whatever reason, just want me to be wrong because I specified your general claim as too general to be accurate. If you disagree that's fine. Show me the science...
BMR for males is (weight in lb) x 12, females (weight in lb) x 11
TEF: BMR x .1 (if high carb diet), or BMR x .05 (if high fat diet)
PA: BMR x .25 for sedentary individuals, .5 for moderate intensity exercising (3-7 hours/week), .75 for more than 7 hours of intense weekly exercise. Exactly what number to use is based on clinician experience and client reporting.
BF: add BMR + TEF + PA to get TEE. This assumes a fit male (18% bf), or fit female (22% bf). If, for example, TheEngineer is 25% bf, he would multiply TEE x .93 (25-18 = 7), being that someone with higher bf burns fewer calories than a fitter person. If someone were say 15% bf, you would do TEE x 1.03 (18-15). That gets an accurate measurement of TEE. Sorry if my calculations look odd, it works easier in my head.
I'm guessing a lot of posters here will do the calculation and say, "holy **** this can't be right. It says I need so many more calories than I eat." Sorry, it's right. It's been efficated many times over and usually the first hurdle I deal with for clients. A lot people burn amino acids for energy and don't understand why they can't get leaner. The vast majority of the time it's because your metabolism has slowed to the point of protein sparing and that was why I made the suggestion to increase total calories very slowly. Your metabolism can be trained, but not very quickly.
Also, sorry. I have no idea what a low-carb tard is. Are you suggesting I eat too many carbs or too few?