Quote:
Originally Posted by whiskylover
I'm pretty new to really getting into bourbon but have made up for lost time and have gotten really immersed into it. Have tried and have over 50 bottles already.
My opinion is to avoid most of the list you provided when staring off as those are primarily craft bottles and most craft have a ways to go.
I'd consider something from the list below to get started.
Buffalo Trace
Eagle Rare
Russel Reserve 10 yr
Evan Williams Single Barrel
Henry McKenna Single Barrel 10yr
Elijah Craig
Knob Creek Small Batch
Four Roses small batch or single barrel
All are somewhat available under $40 and in the 86 to 100 proof range. All are good representations of the bourbon profile.
My preference would be McKenna, Elijah Craig if it's the old bottle with 12yr age statement on front or back, Russel Reserve 10yr, Eagle Rare and Buffalo Trace if you can find a barrel select. A lot of people like four roses but I didn't care much for it, it seems like there having supply issues and quality has dropped in the past year or so.