Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Whisky Whisky

03-10-2017 , 07:03 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by thabighurt35
nice score, I never see places around here even put that on the shelf.



I would not mix, just enjoy as is. At least at first.


Thanks in a way it's a curse since I've been going all over town trying to find more but no luck.

Thought about it and agree, won't be mixing.
Whisky Quote
03-10-2017 , 08:14 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by whiskylover
I almost stopped buying whisky but those 2 for €132 were too good to pass up...
That's a great deal!
Whisky Quote
03-15-2017 , 01:08 AM
Glassware nerds,

Got these as a present:



These glasses are GREAT. The crappy picture doesn't really show them off well, check out the website https://norlanglass.com

I'm a fan of the glencairn glasses, but I like these a lot more for two reasons. First off, they just feel better to hold. More importantly, though, the smell when you drink the whiskey is way less alcohol forward. The difference in taste is really noticeable.

The only downside is they are very light and I think they'd feel better with just a little more heft to them. But overall they're great and I highly recommend them.
Whisky Quote
03-15-2017 , 03:48 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IMDABES
extreme noobie here, have never really drank much booze outside of shots, I had my first old fashioned last weekend and enjoyed not having beer **** my stomach up. I want to get a bottle for home to just try and sip with water or something, what would be a good bottle to get? Jamison is abaout the only kind I have exp with at all, and I'd like to venture out. lets say $50-$100 price range.


Balvenie Doublewood is a pretty safe bet if you're looking for a scotch.
Whisky Quote
03-15-2017 , 07:40 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IMDABES
extreme noobie here, have never really drank much booze outside of shots, I had my first old fashioned last weekend and enjoyed not having beer **** my stomach up. I want to get a bottle for home to just try and sip with water or something, what would be a good bottle to get? Jamison is abaout the only kind I have exp with at all, and I'd like to venture out. lets say $50-$100 price range.
I was in your situation a couple years ago in terms of going from having old fashioneds at bars inspiring me to get some bottles of bourbon for home. I just started going through the basics -- Makers Mark, Buffalo Trace, Bulliet, Woodford Reserve, working myself up to Blanton's.
Whisky Quote
03-15-2017 , 08:45 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IMDABES
extreme noobie here, have never really drank much booze outside of shots, I had my first old fashioned last weekend and enjoyed not having beer **** my stomach up. I want to get a bottle for home to just try and sip with water or something, what would be a good bottle to get? Jamison is abaout the only kind I have exp with at all, and I'd like to venture out. lets say $50-$100 price range.


Jameson is a bit harsh and if you intend on making Old Fashions at home not a good choice. I'd go for something like Buffalo Trace which should be less than $25. I think rye is great for making manhattans or old fashions and would get either Rittenhouse or Sazerac both run about $25. If you like the Buffalo Trace neat it opens up a whole world of bourbons to explore. Also as Gaddy recommended Woodford would be a good choice for someone starting out with bourbon neat or on the rocks, readily available and around $30. It's a bit too smooth and boring for me now but a great introduction into bourbon.
Whisky Quote
03-18-2017 , 01:22 AM
Well this might possibly be the best whiskey I've ever had.





Whisky Quote
03-18-2017 , 03:40 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gaddy
I was in your situation a couple years ago in terms of going from having old fashioneds at bars inspiring me to get some bottles of bourbon for home. I just started going through the basics -- Makers Mark, Buffalo Trace, Bulliet, Woodford Reserve, working myself up to Blanton's.
Makers mark was my first bottle, drank it with water and it was pretty good. Before I get flamed for that I know i know I'm a wimp, I have a plan, am working way up, I'm at whiskey drinking micros now, or freerolls even.

Thanks for recommendations.
Whisky Quote
03-18-2017 , 03:41 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Da_Nit
Jameson is a bit harsh and if you intend on making Old Fashions at home not a good choice. I'd go for something like Buffalo Trace which should be less than $25. I think rye is great for making manhattans or old fashions and would get either Rittenhouse or Sazerac both run about $25. If you like the Buffalo Trace neat it opens up a whole world of bourbons to explore. Also as Gaddy recommended Woodford would be a good choice for someone starting out with bourbon neat or on the rocks, readily available and around $30. It's a bit too smooth and boring for me now but a great introduction into bourbon.
This will be my next bottle, thanks.
Whisky Quote
03-21-2017 , 04:28 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by El Diablo
These glasses are GREAT. The crappy picture doesn't really show them off well, check out the website https://norlanglass.com
hmmmmmmm... interesting implications
Whisky Quote
03-21-2017 , 07:44 PM
Nit - I had a 7 year bottle of old scout and was greatly disappointing. Wonder how much of a factor the extra age makes.
Whisky Quote
03-21-2017 , 11:16 PM
Big,

I have these two and think they are both great:



Only 7 and 8 years old, but cask strength single barrel.
Whisky Quote
03-24-2017 , 09:46 AM
could be the cask strength and could just be the batch. I guess I will try again.

It has been a while but I just remember it being not very complex with the burn being the most prominent, and I usually enjoy the higher ABV stuff.
Whisky Quote
03-24-2017 , 11:40 AM
Big,

Quote:
Originally Posted by El Diablo
American whiskey fans,

Picked up these guys yesterday:


The bourbon from Cask was ~$45, rye from K&L ~$55.

First thing I noticed about both of these is how sweet they are. Definitely a sweeter/fruiter flavor profile than most. They were also both quite drinkable without water even at this high proof.

Rye: very smooth, quite sweet and fruity as I mentioned, and a nice peppery spice finish on the end. Feels a little more balanced and restrained compared to other ryes I like that have more of a spicy, peppery pop to them. Will have to try some side-by-side comparisons. Overall, def liked it and would recommend.

Bourbon: again, lot of sweetness here, more caramel than fruit but still quite a bit of fruit. a little hotter than the rye. smooth enough to drink straight, but def can handle some water. after the sweetness, quite a bit of oak in the middle. nice long finish. Overall, liked this one too and would also recommend.

I think they're very tasty, but they are pretty straightforward sweet fruity flavor profiles and definitely not too complex. And there's certainly quite a bit of heat prominent. The four roses single barrels I've also reviewed are definitely more complex flavor profiles.
Whisky Quote
03-27-2017 , 01:55 PM
so today is like international whisky day or something. enjoy it fellas
Whisky Quote
03-28-2017 , 03:08 PM
got me some clowns

All 3 are young sherried south shore Islay whiskies.
They were so pretty i had to.....
Whisky Quote
03-30-2017 , 11:44 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IMDABES
extreme noobie here, have never really drank much booze outside of shots, I had my first old fashioned last weekend and enjoyed not having beer **** my stomach up. I want to get a bottle for home to just try and sip with water or something, what would be a good bottle to get? Jamison is abaout the only kind I have exp with at all, and I'd like to venture out. lets say $50-$100 price range.
This is still my favorite bourbon by a large margin. Way better than stuff much more expensive ($26.99 in NH). You should have no problem drinking it neat. Very smooth and tasty, highly recommended.

Last edited by RichGangi; 03-30-2017 at 11:44 AM. Reason: Jameson is not harsh at all, WTF??!!
Whisky Quote
03-30-2017 , 11:52 AM
Oh crap ^^ Eagle Rare 10 is a good recommendation. May not necessarily be on the shelf but should be able to find without to much trouble.
Whisky Quote
03-30-2017 , 02:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gaddy
I was in your situation a couple years ago in terms of going from having old fashioneds at bars inspiring me to get some bottles of bourbon for home. I just started going through the basics -- Makers Mark, Buffalo Trace, Bulliet, Woodford Reserve, working myself up to Blanton's.
Just finished my first bottle of this, drank it with water, pretty good actually.
Whisky Quote
03-30-2017 , 02:01 PM
Thanks for recommendation rich gangi, Think I'm going to order that one asap, any recommended sites for ordering online?
Whisky Quote
03-31-2017 , 06:35 AM
Never used them, but I've heard good things about The Whiskey Exchange and K&L.
Whisky Quote
04-10-2017 , 10:40 AM
Hi again!

I'm seriously back into the hobby, cut down my weekly consumption from one bottle to a half. For anyone interested in the a bit extensive process, it's all there in the OOT Quitting Alcohol thread. Anyhow, 100ml of Old Pultney 12 is just like velvet. Think I never definitely can say goodbye to the single malts, they are just too good to be true


Last edited by plaaynde; 04-10-2017 at 10:45 AM.
Whisky Quote
04-10-2017 , 04:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by plaaynde
Hi again!

I'm seriously back into the hobby, cut down my weekly consumption from one bottle to a half.
Half a bottle is probably what i drink in a month,if i count in the fairs and tastings i attend too
Whisky Quote
04-10-2017 , 06:59 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by whiskylover
Half a bottle is probably what i drink in a month,if i count in the fairs and tastings i attend too
A true connoisseur!
Whisky Quote
04-14-2017 , 07:20 PM
Local bar has a blind taste test tonight where you get flights of Maker's Mark, Larceny, Rebel Yell and Van Winkle Special Reserve 12 Year for $35 and try to pick the Pappy. Worth it?
Whisky Quote

      
m