Quote:
Originally Posted by Yeti
on paper it looks good, in practice i fear it most likely just leads to every other fight being champ v champ
yes, people will just float back and forth between divisions to get the fights they want, eliminating the purpose of divisions in the first place.
adding more divisions would be bad for the sport. it would benefit the safety of the fighters but that would be the only benefit.
how do you populate the new divisions? as big as the UFC roster is, there aren't enough fighters to make new divisions. you would cannibalize other divisions to make the new ones.
for example, there are 53 fighters at 185. if you add 175 and 195, you'll absolutely decimate 185. now you're down to 25 fighters at 185. once the numbers get that low you don't even have a division anymore. before long you're setting up bad mismatches because you've got #4 fighting #11 and murdering him when they would have been #37 under the old system.
ideally for the UFC, there would be no weight division and they would have the freedom to match anyone against anyone. ideally for the fighters, there would be a new weight division every 1.5 lbs. a good equilibrium is probably right around where the divisions are now.