What happens when we fail to value bet?
Otherwise known as, "I can't win because they always suck out on me!"
First, the ideal situation. Three streets of value from a calling station:
Villain is 40/3/0.1 after 80 hands. His preflop limping range is huge. When he check/calls flop his range is something like A2/A3/A4/A6/A7/A8/AT/AJ/89/9T/56/45/67/78/55/99. AQ/A9/A5 are possible but you have to think even someone this passive is leading a lot of the time.
So we are well ahead of his calling range even though our kicker is marginal.
Full Tilt Poker $0.01/$0.02 No Limit Hold'em - 9 players
MP2: $1.32
CO: $3.78
BTN: $1.66
SB: $0.77
Hero (BB): $2.00
UTG: $2.04
UTG+1: $2.00
UTG+2: $0.71
MP1: $2.32
Pre Flop: ($0.03) Hero is BB with A

8

UTG calls $0.02, UTG+1 calls $0.02, UTG+2 calls $0.02,
1 fold, MP2 calls $0.02, CO calls $0.02,
2 folds, Hero checks
Flop: ($0.13) 5

A

9
(6 players)
Hero bets $0.10, UTG folds, UTG+1 calls $0.10, UTG+2 folds, MP2 folds, CO folds
Turn: ($0.33) 6
(2 players)
Hero bets $.25, UTG+1 calls
River: ($0.83) J
(2 players)
Hero bets $0.75, UTG+1 calls
Final pot: $2.33 - $.12 rake
UTG+1 shows: A2
Hero wins: $2.21 ($1.09 in profit)
According to PokerStove, our equity on the flop is almost 71% but we only win 54.08% of the time:
Board: 5s Ah 9c
Dead:
equity win tie pots won pots tied
Hand 0: 70.859% 54.08% 16.78% 4283 1329.00 { As8c }
Hand 1: 29.141% 12.36% 16.78% 979 1329.00 { A2s, A2o }
Please read that again - Even though we have a dominating hand and appear to be way ahead, we're actually only winning 54.08% because we wind up splitting the pot 16.78% of the time. What's more,
the calling station will outdraw us almost 30% of the time!
In a split pot, the worst case scenario is that stacks go in and we lose a full $.10 to the rake. For simplicity sake we're just going to make this assumption that for any split pot we lose $.10.
54.08% of the time we win $1.09.
16.78% of the time we lose $.10.
29.14% of the time we lose ???.
So how much do we lose?
With TPNK against a calling station we are folding if he ever raises. He's basically never raising with a worse hand and even when he has a monster he's not always raising - Either because he's slowplaying or just because he's a station.
If he hits his 2pair on the turn and raises this hand costs us $.37.
If he hits his 2pair on the river and raises (or slowplays the turn) this hand costs us $1.12. Whether he raises river or just calls out third barrel doesn't matter. We lose the hand either way - by folding or at showdown.
So how often are we folding the turn and how often are we folding the river/losing showdown?
When he hits his 2pair, half the time he's going to hit it on the turn and half the time on the river. However, he's just calling the turn with 2pair a significant amount of the time. So I'm going to estimate that he raises the turn 25% of the time and we see the river the other 75% of the time.
So when we lose, we lose ($.37x.25+$1.12x.75) $.93.
54.08% of the time we win $1.09.
16.78% of the time we lose $.10.
29.14% of the time we lose $.93.
Our expected value from this hand is ($1.09x.5408-$.10x.1678-$.93x.2914) $.30. On average we will make $.30 on this hand.
Except there's one thing missing here. That's when we
both make 2pair. When this happens we're going to win more than $1.09. But I'm not goign to go down this road because it requires a lot of assumptions about when a station will stack off. So instead just keep in mind that we actually average slightly more than $.30.
So that's what happens when we keep our foot on the gas and take our opponent on a ride to valuetown.
What happens when we blink?
Full Tilt Poker $0.01/$0.02 No Limit Hold'em - 9 players
MP2: $1.32
CO: $3.78
BTN: $1.66
SB: $0.77
Hero (BB): $2.00
UTG: $2.04
UTG+1: $2.00
UTG+2: $0.71
MP1: $2.32
Pre Flop: ($0.03) Hero is BB with A

8

UTG calls $0.02, UTG+1 calls $0.02, UTG+2 calls $0.02,
1 fold, MP2 calls $0.02, CO calls $0.02,
2 folds, Hero checks
Flop: ($0.13) 5

A

9
(6 players)
Hero bets $0.10, UTG folds, UTG+1 calls $0.10, UTG+2 folds, MP2 folds, CO folds
Turn: ($0.33) 6
(2 players)
Hero checks, UTG+1 checks
River: ($0.33) J
(2 players)
Hero checks, UTG+1 checks
Final pot: $.33 rake $.01
UTG+1 shows: A2
Hero wins: $.32 ($.20 in profit)
This is a really simplified case. We've assumed that villain checks it through here as well,
even when he hits 2pair. Even the worst calling stations will bet there when they river 2pair. They're also betting their one pair hands sometimes after we check two streets. And of course we will hit out 2pair sometimes too.
Even though villain cooperates by checking it down, we're still only winning 54.08% of the time. However, because we've kept the pot small, I'm going to estimate that we only lose $.05 to a split pot as villain isn't going to stack off nearly as often. And of course we still lose 29.14% of the time.
54.08% of the time we win $.20.
16.78% of the time we lose $.05.
29.14% of the time we lose $.12.
Our expected value from this hand is ($.20x.5408-$.05x.1678-$.12x.2914) $.06. On average we will make $.06 on this hand.
Again, we've basically ignored the effects of 2pair over 2pair. But we're going to ignore it in all cases because it's difficult to model accurately (how often do we play for stacks?) and they should (more or less) cancel each other out because they occur just as often in all these cases.
Full Tilt Poker $0.01/$0.02 No Limit Hold'em - 9 players
MP2: $1.32
CO: $3.78
BTN: $1.66
SB: $0.77
Hero (BB): $2.00
UTG: $2.04
UTG+1: $2.00
UTG+2: $0.71
MP1: $2.32
Pre Flop: ($0.03) Hero is BB with A

8

UTG calls $0.02, UTG+1 calls $0.02, UTG+2 calls $0.02,
1 fold, MP2 calls $0.02, CO calls $0.02,
2 folds, Hero checks
Flop: ($0.13) 5

A

9
(6 players)
Hero bets $0.10, UTG folds, UTG+1 calls $0.10, UTG+2 folds, MP2 folds, CO folds
Turn: ($0.33) 6
(2 players)
Hero bets $.25, UTG+1 calls
River: ($0.83) J
(2 players)
Hero checks, UTG+1 checks
Final pot: $.83 rake $.04
UTG+1 shows: A2
Hero wins: $.79 ($.42 in profit)
This is a really simplified case. We've assumed that villain checks it through here as well,
even when he hits 2pair. Even the worst calling stations will bet there when they river 2pair. They're also betting their one pair hands sometimes after we check two streets. And of course we will hit out 2pair sometimes too.
Even though villain cooperates by checking it down, we're still only winning 54.08% of the time. However, because we've kept the pot small, I'm going to estimate that we only lose $.07 to a split pot as villain isn't going to stack off nearly as often. And of course we still lose 29.14% of the time.
54.08% of the time we win $.42.
16.78% of the time we lose $.07.
29.14% of the time we lose $.37.
Our expected value from this hand is ($.42x.5408-$.07x.1678-$.37x.2914) $.11. On average we will make $.11 on this hand.
In summary, our EV in these hands when we:
Bet all three streets: $.30
Bet two streets and check it through: $.11
Bet flop and then check it down: $.06
I've only analyzed three very simple cases. Obviously this hand is potentially much more complex. ie; when villain raises or bets somewhere after we take our foot off the gas. When we hit our two pair and get more value than checking it through two streets. However, I'm not going to delve into all these sub cases because I think I've made my point. That failing to value bet costs a ton of value and turns very profitable hands into marginal earners.
If you can't win because the calling stations keep outdrawing you, it's because you're not making enough from the times they
don't out draw you. You're actually usually
not that big a favorite over the calling station so you need to squeeze every bit of profit out of them you can when your hands hold up. Otherwise these one pair hands turn into only marginal winners and you will have a hard time staying profitable.
There are some important things you should take away from all of this.
In all three cases, the amount of money we lose when we lose the hand is almost as much as the amount we win when our hand holds up. The real difference is in
the frequency of wins versus the loses. We need to take advantage of when we are a favorite because otherwise the difference between winning and losing is not very big.
When we bet two streets instead of one, our EV only (about) doubles. However, when we go from two streets to three streets our EV
almost triples. That's the value of compound interest. That's why we need to keep hammering these guys. Giving up a street of value is absolutely huge because
that third street is by far the most profitable street.
The real key is that the kinds of valuetown hands happen extremely regularly. People like to post about folding KK preflop or folding sets but these situations are relatively uncommon. Marginal one pair hand type situations occur again and again and again. If you are not rigorously exploiting your opponents you are giving up tremendous value over many, many hands. Anyone can bet, bet, bet with a flopped set on a dry board. Anyone can get value from their monsters. It's being able to capitalize on these very common situations that really distinguishes the marginal winners from the good players.