Quote:
Originally Posted by Inso0
"You think you want vanilla servers, but you don't" is the company line, and I think they're absolutely right.
It's mostly the PvP crowd that clamors for it, but it's a serious case of rose-tinted goggles. Vanilla PvP was a lot of fun because of the endless stream of terrible, terrible players you had to pick on. Not because the gameplay was better than it is now.
What also usually happens is the bottom of the barrel flocks to these free servers, armed with bots and hacks that were battle-tested on live servers and have no meaningful safeguards to worry about on free servers.
You wind up with a lot of casual tourists stopping by for a short while, until they remember what life in Vanilla was actually like. Grinds, no/slow mounts, farming, and constantly getting blown the **** up by rogues and mages with on-use items and special consumables in world PvP.
I get it to some extent. I remember my time at Sentinel Hill with some amount of fondness, but I also remember quitting Vanilla WoW pretty quickly to go back to free Ultima Online servers because frankly, Vanilla WoW was incredibly boring at max level.
I also understand the Blizzard commentary with regard to technical limitations and the "Blizzard polish" that they require for officially supported game servers. So much of what made Vanilla WoW what it was consisted of bugs and glitches. Kiting world bosses to cities, wall jumping, ability abuse, etc. What about all the quality of life changes that they'd have to eliminate? Global chat channels? Group finder? Revert addon support to vanilla levels?
Also, how many people played on Nostalrius because it was free?
I just don't buy it.
I agree with a lot of this. We've probably discussed this before, but most of the nostalgia for vanilla comes from the sense of community that existed there which does not exist today and really hasn't since TBL. And yeah, a lot about vanilla did suck, some of which you touched on.
What I do NOT buy is what LK referred to, this business about "oops we left the code in our jeans pocket and mom did a wash and now its gone forever." They're getting ready to re-release Diablo I (a much older game) aren't they? They could do this if they felt arsed.
And I do think that despite all the negatives of vanilla there would be some people who would do it, maybe not a lot, but not none and I think enough to make it worthwhile, but that's just MHO YMMV ETC ETC