Originally Posted by ohead
I have replayed it as well and I thought it was holding up fine. If you let go of your graphics driven mind and appreciate it for what it is it's still a lot better. But yeah obviously with a story like that it will get a little drop next time you play but that has nothing to do with the game being dated.
It is holding up 'fine', it just was in my top 3 best games before. I remembered the story to be much better (it still is way above average for video game standards). and fwiw i must've played it 3-4 times some years ago so i already knew the twist back when i ranked it so highly.