Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list?

09-26-2011 , 05:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by AJW
The nominations so far

This is getting hard to keep track of but we have our first two inductees. Please no more votes for inducted games.

Inducted
Final Fantasy 7
Super Mario 64


Chrono Trigger ( 3 )
Descent ( 2 )
Rome total war
Earthbound ( 4 )
Ultima online ( 2 )
Banjo-Kazooie
Team fortress 2
Super metroid ( 2 )
Legend of Zelda ( 2 )
Super mario64 ( 3 )
Zelda OOT ( 4 )
Golden eye ( 2 )
Doom 2 ( 2 )
X-Com
Res Evil 2
MGS
Sarcraft (4)
Diablo 2 (4)
Mario Kart 64 ( 4)
GTA3 ( 2 )
Twisted Metal 2 ( 2 )
Tomb Raider
Donkey Kong country ( 4 )
SSBM 64
Pokeman Red/Blue (2)
Half Life 2
Star Countrole
Dragon age
Mass effect
Amnesia, the void
Secret of Mana ( 2 )
FF 3
Killer Instinct
Quake 3 ( 2 )
Planet scape
Fallout
Fallout 2
Baldurs gate
Deus ex
System shock



Don't forget you can second other peoples nominations while you put your own forward
10 characters
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-26-2011 , 06:35 PM
well i'll obviously second starcraft
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-26-2011 , 06:38 PM
I'll second Quake 3
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-26-2011 , 07:01 PM
Diablo 2
Counter-Strike 1.6/Source
Starcraft 1/2
Mario Kart 64


That is all.
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-26-2011 , 09:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by sspoker008
i think aging well should be a criteria because if a game isn't still fun today then that just means there are tons of better games that have come out since the games release.
I don't really think that's true

Monkey Island for example is legendary but aged horribly, and just about the entire adventure genre since then has been crap
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-26-2011 , 11:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by *******
I don't really think that's true

Monkey Island for example is legendary but aged horribly, and just about the entire adventure genre since then has been crap
exactly.
For me FF7 was a fantastic experience but there is no way I can go back to it nowadays.
So FF7 top 100 yes but personnaly I wouldn't run it again,i.e aged poorly(opposed to goldeneye which I still find fun to play,I can't stand ff7 battle music 1 more sec )
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-26-2011 , 11:31 PM
Mario kart 64
NHL 99
Diablo 2
Team fortress 2
Red dead redemption
Cod MW 2
Final fantasy 7
Crysilis
Twisted metal 2
Tony hawk 2
Nfl blitz
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-26-2011 , 11:34 PM
My list just gave me mad boners.

I ruled so hard at tony hawk...
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-26-2011 , 11:56 PM
second THPS 2, spawned its own genre. also, i nominate SSX Tricky for Xbox. best snowboarding/one of best racing games ever.
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-27-2011 , 12:43 AM
THPS combined music and gaming in an unprecedented way, in addition to spawning its own genre

It should be in there somewhere, I'm not sure which one though

I liked 4
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-27-2011 , 01:44 AM
Problem with goldeneye has a lot to do with the controls and playability. I won't even hold the graphics against it, it just feels very clunky and mediocre.
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-27-2011 , 02:00 AM
controversial nomination: Crazy Taxi on Dreamcast? could play that game 4eva
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-27-2011 , 02:12 AM
Starcraft 1/2, Diablo II obv
Zelda OoT
Tetris
Final Fantasy Tactics
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-27-2011 , 04:14 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheCapn22
Final Fantasy Tactics
favorite game of all time
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-27-2011 , 11:56 AM
Warcraft III
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-27-2011 , 12:28 PM
Second:
CS 1.6/Source
Nominate:
WoW... obv.
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-27-2011 , 01:38 PM
Nominate Portal.

Nominate Shadowrun (SNES), but it's a long shot. I would definitely put it on my personal list.

Nominate Space Quest 3 - definitely one of the best adventure games ever, but it's going to be tough narrowing down which of the Space Quests/King's Quests/Leisure Suit Larry games go on the list.

Nominate Leisure Suit Larry 6.


Second Red Dead Redemption.
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-27-2011 , 01:49 PM
+1 Portal
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-27-2011 , 02:30 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JuntMonkey
Nominate Leisure Suit Larry 6.

[/b].
Isn't that really nominating tweenage masturbation?
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-27-2011 , 02:41 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ThaSaltCracka
Problem with goldeneye has a lot to do with the controls and playability. I won't even hold the graphics against it, it just feels very clunky and mediocre.
Goldeneye is still Top 100, but it does have one huge AI flaw that should hurt its ranking: Enemies can't see (and thus won't shoot you) through waist-high barriers like railings. I don't think I noticed it or fully processed it when I was playing Goldeneye originally, but once you do, any level with stairs and railings plays really ugly.
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-27-2011 , 02:57 PM
Induct Zelda: OOT
Nominate Super Mario Brothers - quite possibly the biggest leap forward in video gaming of all time. Blew the competition out of the water and finally showed off how incredible video games could be.
Nominate Street Fighter 2 - revolutionary. Effectively created a genre. Flawless, smooth controls unlike Mortal Kombat's clunky moves. (SF4 deserves credit for making fighting games popular again, but it can't compete with 2)
Nominate Crash Bandicoot - best linear platformer ever? Tight, precise controls made playing this game a dream.
Nominate Madden ... 97? - I'm not a huge sports game fan but any top 100 without Madden is probably unfair.
Nominate House of the Dead 2 (arcade) - arcade games seriously under rep'd here.
Nominate Initial D (Arcade) - Bit of a niche market game but building your own unique car that you save to a card and drifting against strangers with it is a great experience.
Nominate Katamari Damacy - less than 1 million dollar budget and reminded us that innovation is vital to gaming. Indie before indie was cool.
+1 to Starcraft
+1 to Goldeneye (people are seriously not giving this game proper credit here)
+1 to Tony Hawk 2
+1 to Quake 3
+1 to Resident Evil 2
+1 to Counterstrike
+1 to Tetris
+1 to SSX tricky (I liked other ssx games better but whatever. Took what THPS2 did with soundtracks and made it 10 times better)
-1 to NFL Blitz
-1 to Crazy Taxi
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-27-2011 , 03:29 PM
i second deus ex if it hasn't already been second'ed
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-27-2011 , 03:35 PM
I nominate Tekken 3
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-27-2011 , 03:40 PM
I unnominate Tekken 3.
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote
09-27-2011 , 03:46 PM
second *edit TETRIS* might be far and away the best. also
diablo 2, twisted metal 2, metal gear, counterstrike.
Any Interest in compiling our own 100 best games of all time list? Quote

      
m