Fish,
Overall a B+, a quality consistent theme pervades throughout. Now John Cole and Andy Fox would smirk into their hands some and do a bit and of eye rolling, but being gentleman they would keep comments to themselves and only on the sly. And if they did poke fun, it would be in a friendly and jovial manner and not mean-spirited. But that aside, the house is you and no need to apologize to anyone about that at all. Stick to your guns.
A few comments: Yellow paint should go, even if it is the basement. Use an off white; it will also brighten up the basement. Bonus points for the pronghorn on the wall and I think it deserves a more prominent place in your home.
The three pictures on the wall in a descending line are fine but the fish on either side need repositioning. Put the big fish on the other side of the Wal-Mart rack thingy. Place the smaller fish in the hallway or something. Also the cinderblock wall needs covering. Get some light wood paneling and cover it up. Knotty Pine would work. Then paint the other walls a color the matches well with the blue ceiling. Add more lighting. Use floor lamps with a western theme.
The large hour glass thingy by the TV - Shotgun that up please.
Super bonus points for the garish red tint lamps; they are the nuts. Hits that fine line and perfect blend of bad taste and wry humor that really sets off the room. Well done – You earned
The Special John Cole Star of Approval. No one else got that. Be proud.
Keep shoot'em up.
-Zeno