Quote:
Originally Posted by sightless
i really don't understand how anyone can feel that way about The Piano Teacher. It is just an unpleasant movie, where the character motivations are completely haphazard.
While it might be "unpleasant" to some degree (no more so than, say,
Salo or
I Stand Alone or
Henry, Portrait of a Serial Killer), I would definitely not call any of the motivations "haphazard."
To call Erika's motivations haphazard is odd, as it is clear she is mentally ill, and that she is conflicted as to just how far she wants to follow her mentally ill instincts. She is seen ineffectively trying to rein in her madness in order to at least try to experience normal "love."
As for Walter, his actions are in no way "haphazard" either. He reminds me of Jeffery Beaumont (
Blue Velvet), in that he is conflicted about what Erika wants (totally alien to him), but then, perhaps out of wanting to please her, tries to comply, only to (maybe) find himself enjoying the dynamic he had never before explored.
What is "haphazard" about this?
Not arguing, just asking.