Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Walrus Sign Ups Walrus Sign Ups

01-30-2014 , 03:54 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Willi
Grumpy people give low scores for people who did not like their songs or it creates some weird situations with scoring when someone who is in good spot scores last or something.
Everybody can be done scoring before the reveal starts and we think this would be an issue submit the scores to an outside party.
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 03:58 PM
and if one player from ten goes missing then we can wait forever that reveal
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 04:02 PM
Or he can send it later and we'll just have to trust he's bitter ****.
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 04:08 PM
If you guys want, You can ship the scores to me

I will reveal it

Let you guys judge it

Would be better to try this with a smaller field like Willi suggested imo
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 04:15 PM
If we're doing my suggestion I think max 10 otherwise we'll get too many categories.
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 04:22 PM
I'm in either way nick, let's do it.
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 04:25 PM
in
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 05:22 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by soma84
2013 turbo walrus
i stand by this statement. in whatever shape or form this happens.
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 06:08 PM
Could make the turbos a double blind so you don't know who is judging which category & who submitted each song for your review.

Would require a game moderator/facilitator though to take like a top 3 list for categories each player wants, assigning a category to each, posting the list of categories, receiving the entries, & then shipping them off to the scorer of that category.

& anyone who doesn't grade their category within X amount of time would be disqualified.

Sounds complicated.
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 06:14 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JMurder3
Could make the turbos a double blind so you don't know who is judging which category & who submitted each song for your review.

Would require a game moderator/facilitator though to take like a top 3 list for categories each player wants, assigning a category to each, posting the list of categories, receiving the entries, & then shipping them off to the scorer of that category.

& anyone who doesn't grade their category within X amount of time would be disqualified.

Sounds complicated.
It's a good idea and doesn't have to be complicated.

1. Everyone claims a category in the signup
2. Everyone ships their entry to the moderator
3. Moderator ships the songs to the player who should score them
4. Reveal when ready

Edit: ok you were talking of double blind, yeah that would be complicated. just blind scoring would be easy though
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 06:24 PM
Yeah, just need a mod as the go between.

Edit ie everyone submits to the mod, mod ships lists without names to judge for each cat, judges send back scores and notes, mod puts names back on songs and reveals.
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 06:44 PM
I like nicks suggestion. Will force me to discover some new music too which is awesome
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 06:54 PM
Super in for the 2013 turbo
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 07:04 PM
Yeah, single blind would be easy. If we didn't want people to try to pander to things they know about the judge, that would be more complicated.

Not really a necessary aspect, though, & an unneeded layer of difficulty.
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 07:07 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JMurder3
Yeah, single blind would be easy. If we didn't want people to try to pander to things they know about the judge, that would be more complicated.

Not really a necessary aspect, though, & an unneeded layer of difficulty.
You could even do that with a single mod - everyone sends their cat to the mod who posts them. But part of walrus is knowing your judge. (and part is smacking down people who just try to pander, but not everyone shares my opinion on that)
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 07:08 PM
Yay, looks like we're doing this. Since we're going to have to cap the number of entrants I think people calling it in here have dibs.

gambit
fnord
soma
jabo
zay
Tbob
mexi
nick
Murder
Did I miss anyone?

So we already have 9. Maybe room for 1-2 more? We could just claim categories and get this rolling, shouldn't be complicated.
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 07:09 PM
in
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 07:10 PM
I guess we need to make sure everyone in has the time to do this, I'd be up for it whenever but have more time by the end of next week.
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 07:19 PM
in or waitlist or whatever
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 07:20 PM
I can be out if people are really really excited about it, or can mod & not judge or submit if y'all want.
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 07:20 PM
1. claim categories ~now
2. entries sent to mod in 2 days
3. reveal at will

I guess the reveal at will part is sketchy, but it shouldn't take too much time to listen to and score 10 songs.
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 07:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nick Royale
I guess we need to make sure everyone in has the time to do this, I'd be up for it whenever but have more time by the end of next week.
For like 10 songs from 2013? No sweat.
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 07:21 PM
Claim category in thread or via pm?
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 07:23 PM
I think we can claim in thread. Or do we want it double blind? Sounds like an experiment for a later turbo imo
Walrus Sign Ups Quote
01-30-2014 , 07:25 PM
gambit (mod?)
fnord
soma
jabo
zay
Tbob
mexi
nick
Murder (mod?)
Roo
Lenc
Walrus Sign Ups Quote

      
m