so that now everyone's had some input, i think this is where we stand:

forsyth in rd 1, vix in rd 4, tehtoes in rd 2 - seem to be consensus.

so the debates are aj/thenothing for rd 2/3. necro/willi for rd 3/4.

seems like everybody had me rd 3 initially, until some more thought was involved. and everybody had tn rd 1 or 2 initially. so it seems TN in rd 2, aj in rd 3 would be the way to go.

seems close to an even split on how to place necro/willi for round 3/4 with 4 people saying necro is round 3 and 3 saying willi round 3. that seems to be the tougher one to get a consensus on.

I think aj would go before me. his pm sounds better imo.

the thing with Willi/necro, I think Willi might go before necro because he actually mentions he watches survivor. they both talk about being loyal and a team player. I dunno.

One of these is right imo. I don't feel strong in either direction.

Actually me over Necro seems good idea.

3:26 left to lock your answers

I'd put necro over willi. A few seasons of survivor aren't that helpful, imo. For instance, I'm a moderate fan and have watched like 8 seasons in their entireties, but I didn't mention it because I figured there would be people around who had seen every single one and were up on the trivia (ie thenothing), and they'd beat me in every survivor-themed competition. I can only assume that Ibavly had the exact same thought process as me :P

Anyway, just hopped on over to check up on things during my lunch break - I'll be gone until after it's lock-in time. Gl with whatever is agreed upon

I was thinking that seeing all the seasons is not always best. I have seen some big fans playing the game and they seem to have too many ideas about strategic part. So I am not sure if they are most trustworthy people. I do not see any problems with TheNothing, but if I had to pick anonymus then I am not sure if i would pick someone first who has seen all the seasons and is biggest fan in history, because at least me would not trust that player most.

Oh yeah, I don't see me top 2 at all. Maybe 3rd or 4th. Even 5th. We don't know what is most important to the captain. Depends on what he wanted in his team.

Round 1: PM #1 (or name)
Round 2: PM#5, PM#6
Round 3: PM #2, PM #4
Round 4: PM #3, PM #7

OK - We've got a couple of hours before the challenge answer has to be sent.

We can either submit our own order & then take totals that way OR we can make up a couple of different picking orders & vote on it.

Any ideas?

For example, this seems like a decent list

1. Forsythio
2. Tehtoes
3. Nothing
4. AJ
5. Willi
6. Necro
7. Vix

Lets discuss!

I agree.

yes looks reasonable to me.

That's the one I want to lock in

okay cool 4 of 7 have approved

we'll give the others a chance to either agree or give better ideas & then we'll decide on who will send it in.