Rookie Werewolf Game Thread 2 - The Quickening

[norseman1066]

Originally Posted by OneCrazyDuck

order: jamee, source, mused, brian, jv, dustin

These are the picks in order.

[norseman1066]

Sorry wrong seer I quoted there.

[Xr8ed]

subandi

[norseman1066]

Originally Posted by HighPockets

I think I've given strong opinions in several posts. E.g. see my Subandi read or my TN/JV/MoneyMatt theory about the dnky bandwagon on day 2.

As to my reads at the moment.

Wolf on moneymatt, subsandi, TN, JV. Also suspicious of Brian, norse, lucid, vuroth.

Most villagery on twitch, zellic, snafoo.

Netural on everyone else.

I'd say that seeing as he had 5 peeks and it looks like 4 of them were/are wolves then Twitch is most likely his only village peek. Okay then take Twitch off the list. I would also wait to vote for snafoo and xr8ed as well.

[norseman1066]

Updated list:

csma
dkgj (wolf confidence is high)
xr8ed (dnkyhunter) (only if we havent found the wolf by the time we get here)
lucid
snafoo(only lynch if we haven't found a wolf last before xr8ed)
subandi (wolf seer peeked)
caedus (tn)(wolf seer peeked)
vuroth
willd
xtsma
aaron's son (zelic)

[snafoo]

Originally Posted by norseman1066

I'd say that seeing as he had 5 peeks and it looks like 4 of them were/are wolves then Twitch is most likely his only village peek. Okay then take Twitch off the list. I would also wait to vote for snafoo and xr8ed as well.

No way he had 4 wolf peeks and not come out. That would be beyond bad. And by the way, I'm pretty sure he peeked icon.

I think confirmed peeks are (I could be wrong about the order since I'm too lazy to look it up atm):

day 1: icon
day 2: MM
day 3: subandi

I think he was indecisive in his analysis of twitch. Don't remember on what day he wrote that though (reminder to self: I should check that when I have more time). Though I still think twitch is villa, I'm not convinced he was actually a peek.

Note how HP was obvious about MM and Subandi (at least once you know where to look), he is not sending a clear message on anyone else afaik.

ps: xr8ed != Zelic as you seem to imply.

[norseman1066]

I could be wrong but look how he had the wolves listed. It would have been a very good read to have JV as his last wolf and then actually turn up as wolf without a peek. I'm more inclined to beleive that the 4 wolves he listed and put in red with links in a different post are his peeks.

MHO of course. Maybe Dustin and the rest will weigh in on this.

[norseman1066]

My guess about why the wolves didn't nk Elliot is they saw he was on only one wolf and no one was following his leads and he really hadn't left any other peek list so they felt good enough to ignore his TN is a wolf post.

[norseman1066]

There is one last adendum to my list.......if jv was a read and not a peek that would make it more likely that Twitch was infact a peek not a read. IMHO AAR

[snafoo]

Then we should lynch TN after Subandi to find out.

I don't like your suggestion to let the wolves live longer btw. I don't think it is a good idea to let outed wolves live without a very good reason.

[Twitch1977]

While I do like the subandi vote I am more inclined to like the dkgojackets vote.

dkgojackets is never going to give us the posts we need to clear him, he's contributing nothing and the fact he hasn't been modkilled or subbed imo points to the fact he might be a wolf.

At a minimum I'd like to see him used for at least a counter-wagon.

dkgojackets
T

[Willd]

I can't remember who did it and I don't really have time to go look for it just now but someone did some analysis on HP's posts and the conclusion had Zelic (AKSon) as almost certainly being a peek, I think it was either the n3 or n4 peek. As others have said, if he had 3 and especially 4 wolf peeks then not coming out would be coimpletely terrible, which leads me to think that at least 1 of the people he listed wolf probably weren't peeks and I think there are enough reasons to doubt TN being a wolf for him to be one I'm most doubtful of.

[snafoo]

Talking about outed wolves:

I want to know this from everyone who voted jv yesterday:
Why didn't you vote for someone who wasn't on the OCD list?

[sixfour]

[0] brian voted xtsma
[0] dustin (brian0721) voted dkgj
[0] csma
[4] dkgj voted xr8ed
[1] xr8ed (dnkyhunter) voted subandi
[0] jamee voted dkgj
[0] lucid
[0] mused unvoted
[0] snafoo voted subandi
[0] norse (source) voted dkgj
[3] subandi
[0] caedus (tn)
[0] twitch voted dkgj
[0] vuroth voted subandi
[0] willd
[1] xtsma
[0] aaron's son (zelic)

[sixfour]

modnote - i'll be away from the thread from around 2:30est until near to night, so will not be able to provide vote counts, i'll say that night is 8:30est (so about 9:40 from now) so that we don't have any kind of "zomg where's a count wat" cluster****