The Resistance Game Thread - Page 98

hardcoreUFO · 08-12-2012, 02:23 PM

ibav and mets are mind melding, that's sweet.

metsandfinsfan · 08-12-2012, 02:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by metsandfinsfan

if mission 1 fails, then all 3 people on mission one can never be leader or on any team

so they would be stupid to let it fail the more i think about it

if i were a wolf, id prob pick 1 wolf buddy and 1 villager and pass the mission

If this is why people think I'm w/w with luckay I guess I get it

But it's wrong

metsandfinsfan · 08-12-2012, 02:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hardcoreUFO

are you trying to make a case against me?

Idk

I'm stream ling

And you're inconsistent

metsandfinsfan · 08-12-2012, 02:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LuckayLuck

wrong

this game has some subtleties that some will not be able to figure out

I've played this in real life a few times and I'm going to say this: I am holding back some amount of strategy here and I will out it when I feel it is beneficial to do so

if anybody can think of pro-villa strategy and wants to present it you may present it and I may pick you on the team for it

Tell us

LuckayLuck · 08-12-2012, 02:26 PM

quoting this for reference since it's an important point

Quote:

Originally Posted by BombayBadboy

BBB
BLS
Mets
HardcoreUfo

In bold.

Quote:

Originally Posted by reno expat

well, shanks and i basically crossposted on this. he PM'ed me a vote for success so i'm going to count it as an official for and the vote ends 5-5

Player	Vote
BirdieLongSocks	Y
bobman0330	N
BombayBadBoy	Y
domer2	N
hardcoreUFO	Y
ibavly	N
LuckayLuck	N
metsandfinsfan	Y
shanks	Y
thingyman/sangaman	N

Totals
Yes: 5
No: 5

LuckayLuck · 08-12-2012, 02:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BombayBadboy

Work as in not send the team? Not a very big %. Other villagers that at least had the same reasoning and cleared themselves? Very big %.

you are making a very big leap in that a wolf would not vote no on a mission with a wolf

BombayBadboy · 08-12-2012, 02:28 PM

For Mets. And myself. And others..

Ibavly scenarios

If Ibavly is a wolf, one of BBB/Bobman is a wolf if we assume that on both failed teams was just 1 wolf. We are also assuming that both Shanks and BLS are wolves in this scenario.

If Ibavly is a villager, both Bobman and BBB are villagers if we assume that on both failed teams there was just 1 wolf. We are also assuming that Shanks and BLS are wolves in this scenario. Other two: one of Luckay/Mets and one of Sanga/Domer/Hardcore.

Two wolves on team 1

My main problem here is that I'm not totally sure that there was just 1 wolf on the first mission. Luckay is perfectly capable of adding one of his wolfbuddies to the team and voting pass. I think that if there was a team with two wolves on it, it was team 1.

If we make the assumptions that BLS and Shanks are wolves and the assumption that there were two wolves on the first team, Bobman, me, Sanga, Domer and Hardcore are always villagers.

Two wolves on team 2

Assumptions: BLS and Shanks wolves, one wolf on team 1, two on team 2.

Would make BBB/Bobman villagers and Ibavly a wolf.

So, if on either of the teams there were two wolves, Bobman and me are villagers if we assume that BLS and Shanks a wolves. Sanga, Domer can be a wolf in the Ibavly villager scenario.

ibavly · 08-12-2012, 02:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hardcoreUFO

ibav, are you fine with bbb/bob/sanga/mets then?

we need 5 people to win

Ideally I'd like

me
bbb
bob
sanga
domer

But if people insist on excluding me I'd rather have mets than luckay

LuckayLuck · 08-12-2012, 02:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by metsandfinsfan

Tell us

the basics are "look very carefully at vote counts" and "send teams that succeed again"

I didn't want to necessarily tip off the wolves

not too deep but the main thing in this game is that if mission 2 passes the village wins (sends the same team on 3, 4)

BombayBadboy · 08-12-2012, 02:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LuckayLuck

you are making a very big leap in that a wolf would not vote no on a mission with a wolf

Well it didnt happen.

hardcoreUFO · 08-12-2012, 02:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BombayBadboy

Ibavly scenarios

If Ibavly is a wolf, one of BBB/Bobman is a wolf if we assume that on both failed teams was just 1 wolf. We are also assuming that both Shanks and BLS are wolves in this scenario.

If Ibavly is a villager, both Bobman and BBB are villagers if we assume that on both failed teams there was just 1 wolf. We are also assuming that Shanks and BLS are wolves in this scenario. Other two: one of Luckay/Mets and one of Sanga/Domer/Hardcore.

Two wolves on team 1

My main problem here is that I'm not totally sure that there was just 1 wolf on the first mission. Luckay is perfectly capable of adding one of his wolfbuddies to the team and voting pass. I think that if there was a team with two wolves on it, it was team 1.

If we make the assumptions that BLS and Shanks are wolves and the assumption that there were two wolves on the first team, Bobman, me, Sanga, Domer and Hardcore are always villagers.

why can't ibav be the lone wolf in ibav/mets/luckay and then ibav/me/domer/sanga? i don't see how the first paragraph holds true.

if ibav is a villager, the ibav/bbb/bob/me team has a wolf that is one of me/bbb/bob. therefore ibav = v makes bbb or bob a wolf. of course that's from my perspective, right. ibav being a wolf kinda clears bbb and bob because they're both being very villagery and hardly there's a wolf in them.

metsandfinsfan · 08-12-2012, 02:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shanks

Luckayluck howling it up ITT, nothing new there.
Mets if you WEREN'T chosen, what would have to be the situation for you to accept the mission, out of interest? Obviously I know that without me on the mission it is less likely to succeed, as do you (assuming you are a villa), but rejecting ANY mission because it doesn't have you in it seems kinda bad.

I do think it is good for luckayluck to include himself in the mission team regardless.

Interesting

metsandfinsfan · 08-12-2012, 02:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hardcoreUFO

why can't ibav be the lone wolf in ibav/mets/luckay and then ibav/me/domer/sanga? i don't see how the first paragraph holds true.

if ibav is a villager, the ibav/bbb/bob/me team has a wolf that is one of me/bbb/bob. therefore ibav = v makes bbb or bob a wolf. of course that's from my perspective, right. ibav being a wolf kinda clears bbb and bob because they're both being very villagery and hardly there's a wolf in them.

No

hardcoreUFO · 08-12-2012, 02:34 PM

domer can't be a wolf if ibavly is a villager.

that would make the wolf team something like:

luckay/mets
shanks
birdie
XXXX

this last spot has to be one of me/domer/sanga. it also has to be one of me/bbb/bob. that makes ME the wolf. i'm not a wolf.

ATTENTION VILLAGE.

ME AND IBAV ARE LOGICALLY V/W.

PICK YOUR SIDE.

BombayBadboy · 08-12-2012, 02:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hardcoreUFO

why can't ibav be the lone wolf in ibav/mets/luckay and then ibav/me/domer/sanga? i don't see how the first paragraph holds true.

if ibav is a villager, the ibav/bbb/bob/me team has a wolf that is one of me/bbb/bob. therefore ibav = v makes bbb or bob a wolf. of course that's from my perspective, right. ibav being a wolf kinda clears bbb and bob because they're both being very villagery and hardly there's a wolf in them.

Your perspective isnt worth anything for the rest of us. I'm approaching it from a villager standpoint.

The scenario holds, also if Ibavly is the lone wolf. Add BLS and Shanks. You ahve three wolves. Last one is in BBB/Bobman.