The Resistance Game Thread

[sangaman]

Originally Posted by metsandfinsfan

for luckay to choose a wolf partner for his team, hed have to be a complete ****ing idiot

like the dumbest person on the face of the earth

Why would that be so bad? If people actually believe he'd never pick a wolf if he were a wolf then he should pick a wolf just to exploit that.

Who do you think the wolves are?

[sangaman]

Originally Posted by LuckayLuck

I love this team


shanks send it if you want to prove your loyalty

Why would Shanks sending this team prove his loyalty? Anything else he sends will likely be shot down anyway and if anything it'd be a good way for him to antispew.

[sangaman]

Luckay who are the wolves and do you still think I'm a wolf? Did you read my posts about thingy last night?

[hardcoreUFO]

if luckay/birdie/shanks is w/w/w, i have a feeling bob is more likely the last wolf than domer2.

i think sangaman is a villager. but we don't need to figure this out now.

[sangaman]

Originally Posted by hardcoreUFO

if luckay/birdie/shanks is w/w/w, i have a feeling bob is more likely the last wolf than domer2.

i think sangaman is a villager. but we don't need to figure this out now.

Those 3 could be wolves, and domer could be a villager, but why would bob be the last wolf if that's the case?

Why would wolfbob vote no yesterday if BLS is a wolf?

[metsandfinsfan]

Originally Posted by hardcoreUFO

if luckay/birdie/shanks is w/w/w, i have a feeling bob is more likely the last wolf than domer2.

i think sangaman is a villager. but we don't need to figure this out now.

wolves likely
luckay
domer
shanks
bob

imo

[metsandfinsfan]

Originally Posted by sangaman

Those 3 could be wolves, and domer could be a villager, but why would bob be the last wolf if that's the case?

Why would wolfbob vote no yesterday if BLS is a wolf?

because he said he would vote down any team that didnt include himself

[hardcoreUFO]

i think me/mets/ibav/bombay passes the mission.

if people are uncomfortable with mets, we can go me/sangaman/ibav/bombay.

actually just re-read thingy and he isn't as wolfy as some people portrayed him to be. he was also the first one to push shanks. that was followed by luckay, so i guess luckay as a wolf thought that was a good opportunity to bus since apparently shanks is really transparent as a wolf.

like he IS a lock wolf. considering luckay is probably a wolf, there has to be something wrong with the team luckay loved and told shanks to send. i don't think mets is ever a wolf... he can only be w/w with luckay to me. luckay wouldn't vote no on the first mission if that was the case. no way. it's too much fps for it to work.

i don't think we need to absolutely send mets either. i think he is very villagery and i see no reason to believe luckay isn't a wolf. but if it helps the team to pass we can exchange mets for sangaman.... or bob. i don't think we should send birdie.

also fwiw there IS a wolf in sangaman/bob/mets, because ibav/bombay are villagers. otherwise wolf team would have to be exactly domer/luckay/shanks/birdie, and tbh i'm finding somewhat hard to believe now that domer is w/w with luckay. luckay's case against domer is pretty strong fwiw. yesterday i thought for sure that could've been because domer was just acting all weird and wolfy, and luckay was doing all those re-reads and needed to push him, otherwise it would out both. but considering that luckay also bussed shanks, i think it's unlikely he would bus 2/3 of the remaining wolves in his team when the entire village is raising their eyebrows at him.

tbh this game is getting really awful. i don't think luckay/domer are w/w. if domer is a wolf, wolf team has to be domer/mets/shanks/XXX???. that's by far the worst case scenario.

[sangaman]

Originally Posted by metsandfinsfan

wolves likely
luckay
domer
shanks
bob

imo

Why would wolf shanks vote Y to a team of all villagers?

[sangaman]

Originally Posted by metsandfinsfan

because he said he would vote down any team that didnt include himself

Ok but why would he even say this if he has a wolfbro on the team?

[hardcoreUFO]

Originally Posted by LuckayLuck

Shanks' Thought Process









boom

this is a key concept in the resistance



if shanks thought this:



then that means he had 3 people as villagers:

1) Shanks
2) Bombay
3) Hardcore


that leaves only 3 more villagers and as bobman points out aptly if shanks voted "yes" that would have to be exactly luckay, mets, and ibav




good deduction by bobman and I believe shanks is the most likely wolf (yes even more likely than one of mets/ibav)

Originally Posted by LuckayLuck

WE SHOULD VOTE DOWN ANY TEAM DOMER SUGGESTS



so domer voted yes immediately
means that ibavly mets and I were unquestionably village to him





orly






he did not vote yes immediately

his first instinct was to vote against the team


also, early on his biggest wolf read was me


it makes no sense for him to have passed my team and it certainly wasn't going to be "near instantly" as he described

I think he's a wolf

that's too much bussing, man. it can't be luckay/shanks/domer/xxxx.

[hardcoreUFO]

THERE IS A WOLF THAT'S ACTING PRETTY VILLAGERY RIGHT NOW AND WE NEED TO FIND OUT WHO HE IS BEFORE HE KILLS ANY CHANCE OF VICTORY.

luckay is not wolfing with domer.

mets is ALWAYS w/w with domer if he is a wolf.

everytime luckay is a villager, mets and domer are w/w.

everytime luckay is a wolf, mets and domer are v/v.

if above is the case, then there's a villagery guy around who is a wolf. because we need to fill the remaining two wolf spots, and by removing domer from luckay's wolf team we're left with bombay/sandaman/birdie/bob, considering ibav = v and me = v obv.

first spot is easy: birdie, right? i mean looking at these guys it has to be birdie.

second spot i'd say is either bob or sandaman. if bombay is a wolf it's game over anyway.

[reno expat]

i'm sorry about the lack of a team thus far. I've PM'ed shanks. I'm giving him some time because I have no idea what part of the world he is in, but I will sub him if he doesn't pick it up a bit on timely action

[sangaman]

Originally Posted by hardcoreUFO

i think me/mets/ibav/bombay passes the mission.

if people are uncomfortable with mets, we can go me/sangaman/ibav/bombay.

actually just re-read thingy and he isn't as wolfy as some people portrayed him to be. he was also the first one to push shanks. that was followed by luckay, so i guess luckay as a wolf thought that was a good opportunity to bus since apparently shanks is really transparent as a wolf.

like he IS a lock wolf. considering luckay is probably a wolf, there has to be something wrong with the team luckay loved and told shanks to send. i don't think mets is ever a wolf... he can only be w/w with luckay to me. luckay wouldn't vote no on the first mission if that was the case. no way. it's too much fps for it to work.

i don't think we need to absolutely send mets either. i think he is very villagery and i see no reason to believe luckay isn't a wolf. but if it helps the team to pass we can exchange mets for sangaman.... or bob. i don't think we should send birdie.

also fwiw there IS a wolf in sangaman/bob/mets, because ibav/bombay are villagers. otherwise wolf team would have to be exactly domer/luckay/shanks/birdie, and tbh i'm finding somewhat hard to believe now that domer is w/w with luckay. luckay's case against domer is pretty strong fwiw. yesterday i thought for sure that could've been because domer was just acting all weird and wolfy, and luckay was doing all those re-reads and needed to push him, otherwise it would out both. but considering that luckay also bussed shanks, i think it's unlikely he would bus 2/3 of the remaining wolves in his team when the entire village is raising their eyebrows at him.

tbh this game is getting really awful. i don't think luckay/domer are w/w. if domer is a wolf, wolf team has to be domer/mets/shanks/XXX???. that's by far the worst case scenario.

Re: your first sentence, I think we should be thinking in terms of getting a team of all villagers instead of a team that would pass the mission. Those are almost the same but not quite.

I would support a team of you/me/Bombay/ibav. Bombay looked real good earlier in this game and I still think he's a villager but I would like to know more about his wolf game and see him post more.

Agree thingy not as wolfy as he was made out to be. The case for his d1 vote being bad isn't that strong as I tried to demonstrate earlier.

Why are you so confident Luckay is a wolf and mets is a villager? I think you should at least reexamine these beliefs. I think it makes somewhat more sense for Luckay to be a wolf but he has been more pro village than mets and I think the case for mets being spewed clear is exaggerated.

Overall I like/agree with your thought process and there is no 4 man wolf team that makes crystal clear sense at the moment to me either. But I think if we keep discussing the possibilities we might make sense of things. Also we don't necessarily need 4 wolves to win, just 5 villagers.

I'm starting to think hardcore needs to be included on every mission from here on out.

[hardcoreUFO]

actually mets/domer/shanks/xxxx would be simpler to beat. but that's an unlikely team regardless because luckay has to be a wolf.

man i hate this game. a lot. we need a seer.