Once Upon A Time In Pogwarts - Game Thread
03-26-2017
, 10:01 AM
03-26-2017
, 10:05 AM
03-26-2017
, 10:06 AM
03-26-2017
, 10:45 AM
03-26-2017
, 10:51 AM
03-26-2017
, 10:56 AM
This knights/ianaww stuff at the beginning of d3 is kind of weird w/w to me, but I don't really know?
Some random Xkf...
Back to ianaww/knights.
I guess I'm just putting this out here to see if this seems w/w or w/v.
Quote:
some stuff from EoD
specifically donny's vote on well named stood out as really awkward and unnecessary (specially cause he was calling out xkf in the rest of the post)
Ianaww moving to Iraise (which kept iraise as a viable third wagon around xander (wolf) and diceman (possible wolf peek?).
plus the rest of the iraise wagon is not villagery in the slightest, xnerd, jmurder (who had a much weaker day 2 than day 1 imo), and diceman(possible wolf peek).
basically I think killing the iraise wagon is the place to start.
specifically donny's vote on well named stood out as really awkward and unnecessary (specially cause he was calling out xkf in the rest of the post)
Ianaww moving to Iraise (which kept iraise as a viable third wagon around xander (wolf) and diceman (possible wolf peek?).
plus the rest of the iraise wagon is not villagery in the slightest, xnerd, jmurder (who had a much weaker day 2 than day 1 imo), and diceman(possible wolf peek).
basically I think killing the iraise wagon is the place to start.
Quote:
I was just noting that it always throws me off when he refers to village as bros bc IME it's usually used towards fellow wolves.
And I would hardly say it was unnecessary. I was the tying vote on diceman, and me moving off him enabled a wolf lynch last night. Wasn't entirely my intent bc I wasn't completely convinced xander was a wolf (though you can quote my posts near EoD where I say he isn't acting like the normal xander I know). But I didn't feel the dice wagon was good.
And I would hardly say it was unnecessary. I was the tying vote on diceman, and me moving off him enabled a wolf lynch last night. Wasn't entirely my intent bc I wasn't completely convinced xander was a wolf (though you can quote my posts near EoD where I say he isn't acting like the normal xander I know). But I didn't feel the dice wagon was good.
Quote:
people talk to me about my thing about wanting to purge the IRTM wagon.
obviously it may need reconsideration now that I think the diceman thing was just a read, not a peek, but still, that could easily be an attempt to keep a counterwagon at play late into EoD.
chrisV (someone who strongly advocated against xander lynch) and then who said 'gah, diceman' when he voted him, made a brief sojourn there as well.
Ianaww's vote on xander at the end saying 'i trust xkf' feels pretty fake also, cause if he 'trusts xkf' why wouldn't he have just trusted him 5 or 10 min before and just voted xander?
obviously it may need reconsideration now that I think the diceman thing was just a read, not a peek, but still, that could easily be an attempt to keep a counterwagon at play late into EoD.
chrisV (someone who strongly advocated against xander lynch) and then who said 'gah, diceman' when he voted him, made a brief sojourn there as well.
Ianaww's vote on xander at the end saying 'i trust xkf' feels pretty fake also, cause if he 'trusts xkf' why wouldn't he have just trusted him 5 or 10 min before and just voted xander?
Quote:
Knights, how you could possibly think I'm wolfing based on that EOD is baffling.
I had no reason to vote for Xander there. I've been wanting to lynch Dice since D1 and I didn't have any prior commitment to a xander vote. It would have been a very easy thing for me to vote Dice when Iraise didn't go anywhere.
Instead I ultimately trusted Xkf, and it paid off.
I had no reason to vote for Xander there. I've been wanting to lynch Dice since D1 and I didn't have any prior commitment to a xander vote. It would have been a very easy thing for me to vote Dice when Iraise didn't go anywhere.
Instead I ultimately trusted Xkf, and it paid off.
Quote:
the bold are awful reasons to think that you aren't a wolf.
and the underlined is a fine reason, but wolves do silly bussing all the time, and you could be trying to set yourself up for late game, you could be the roleblocker, you could just have alot of money and wanted to stick around, could be a multitude of things.
And that doesn't explain why, if you wanted to lynch dice since day 1, why did you move to IRTM in the first place?
you had a wagon that you liked?
why not just go there, and keep it ahead of a wagon you (admittedly) ended up sheeping xkf on?
that doesn't seem like a villagery thought process to me.
and the underlined is a fine reason, but wolves do silly bussing all the time, and you could be trying to set yourself up for late game, you could be the roleblocker, you could just have alot of money and wanted to stick around, could be a multitude of things.
And that doesn't explain why, if you wanted to lynch dice since day 1, why did you move to IRTM in the first place?
you had a wagon that you liked?
why not just go there, and keep it ahead of a wagon you (admittedly) ended up sheeping xkf on?
that doesn't seem like a villagery thought process to me.
Quote:
My point was I didn't have a commitment to vote for Xander, whereas as a wolf I had an easy excuse to vote for Diceman.
I wasn't pushing hard for diceman lynch, and when there were CFD calls, I thought iraise or cdl would be the best candidates.
What is bizzare is how anything you are posting about me here makes me wolfy. Voting for a wolf based on the suggestion of an elite thread leader? That's wolfy?
If dice is a villager, voting iraise would not be wolfy, right? So dice would have to be a wolf for my iraise vote to be wolfy, but then I was voting dice D1 so - must be bussing?
What is your iraise read atm, knights?
I wasn't pushing hard for diceman lynch, and when there were CFD calls, I thought iraise or cdl would be the best candidates.
What is bizzare is how anything you are posting about me here makes me wolfy. Voting for a wolf based on the suggestion of an elite thread leader? That's wolfy?
If dice is a villager, voting iraise would not be wolfy, right? So dice would have to be a wolf for my iraise vote to be wolfy, but then I was voting dice D1 so - must be bussing?
What is your iraise read atm, knights?
Quote:
right now?
i thought his self vote tantrum was awful and I refuse to read him off it, and I think his play before it was wolfy.
if I had been there at EoD, he is probably who I would have voted (funnily enough) cause I had a villa read on diceman and the slightest of villa reads on xander.
that doesn't really mean anything wrt your alignment tho, because I don't have all the information, so my vote woulda just been a lolknights, and now that xander has flipped, its obvious that people skirting around his lynch are likely wolves.
i thought his self vote tantrum was awful and I refuse to read him off it, and I think his play before it was wolfy.
if I had been there at EoD, he is probably who I would have voted (funnily enough) cause I had a villa read on diceman and the slightest of villa reads on xander.
that doesn't really mean anything wrt your alignment tho, because I don't have all the information, so my vote woulda just been a lolknights, and now that xander has flipped, its obvious that people skirting around his lynch are likely wolves.
Quote:
no
I said I thought he was wolfy YESTERDAY.
based on how the wagons played out, it looks like he was a possible villa counter wagon to a flipped wolf.
so my reads have changed.
Its almost like this is a game where we have to use the new information we gather to inform our reads.
:O
I said I thought he was wolfy YESTERDAY.
based on how the wagons played out, it looks like he was a possible villa counter wagon to a flipped wolf.
so my reads have changed.
Its almost like this is a game where we have to use the new information we gather to inform our reads.
:O
Back to ianaww/knights.
Quote:
first off the bold is really awkward. feels like you're tried intentionally to not spew me as villager, so you added the 'either role' part.
Secondly
if i'm a villager (as is the case), and he's a villager or a wolf on a shot list for not being active, I don't care, cause he's inactive, and I don't want him around for lylo/mylo.
if i'm a wolf and he's a villa, i would still give 0 ****s if he's on shot lists, cause a dead villa would be good for me.
The only scenario in which I DO care, is if I am a wolf, and he is a wolf, which is obviously not the case since, guess what, I don't care.
Secondly
if i'm a villager (as is the case), and he's a villager or a wolf on a shot list for not being active, I don't care, cause he's inactive, and I don't want him around for lylo/mylo.
if i'm a wolf and he's a villa, i would still give 0 ****s if he's on shot lists, cause a dead villa would be good for me.
The only scenario in which I DO care, is if I am a wolf, and he is a wolf, which is obviously not the case since, guess what, I don't care.
Quote:
Has iraise done anything in particular to alter your read on him? Or is it just that he was a late wagon when Xander ultimately flipped?
It looks like you are trying to avoid putting a firm read on him based on his own posts.
If Dice is a villager - why wouldn't I just stick with the Dice plan altogether?
If Dice is a wolf - why would I bus him all day D1 and then not bother D2?
It looks like you are trying to avoid putting a firm read on him based on his own posts.
If Dice is a villager - why wouldn't I just stick with the Dice plan altogether?
If Dice is a wolf - why would I bus him all day D1 and then not bother D2?
Quote:
If you are both villagers, you don't want him to die, no matter what his activity level is, unless you really have nfi who the wolves could be otherwise.
How close are we to must-lynch? THAT is your thought process right now? Not believable.
You're so full of **** right now, max.
How close are we to must-lynch? THAT is your thought process right now? Not believable.
You're so full of **** right now, max.
Quote:
I think he is a villager RIGHT NOW based on how EoD played out.
and no, that has nothing to do with his play, exclusively with wagonomics.
and I did not 'avoid putting a firm read on him' you just deliberately misunderstood what I was saying multiple times when it was obvious what i meant.
and as to the last two, there are multiple possible reasons why or why not for either case,
if he's a villa, you would catch alot of flack for jumping on @ EoD if he did get lynched and flipped villa (specially when xander eventually flipped), or you could decide that trying to get clear at the sake of bussing your bro is better for your long term gameplan.
if he's a wolf, you bussing him all day like a braindead monkey could be percieved as TMI, and just straight up bussing a bro hard like that generally never works out well (ime) cause you never get as much villa cred as you think you do. etc.etc.
but all of this is stuff you should know, you're just asking me retorical questions that mean nothing, which also isn't helping you prove your alignment, or determine mine, which is making this meaningless.
and no, that has nothing to do with his play, exclusively with wagonomics.
and I did not 'avoid putting a firm read on him' you just deliberately misunderstood what I was saying multiple times when it was obvious what i meant.
and as to the last two, there are multiple possible reasons why or why not for either case,
if he's a villa, you would catch alot of flack for jumping on @ EoD if he did get lynched and flipped villa (specially when xander eventually flipped), or you could decide that trying to get clear at the sake of bussing your bro is better for your long term gameplan.
if he's a wolf, you bussing him all day like a braindead monkey could be percieved as TMI, and just straight up bussing a bro hard like that generally never works out well (ime) cause you never get as much villa cred as you think you do. etc.etc.
but all of this is stuff you should know, you're just asking me retorical questions that mean nothing, which also isn't helping you prove your alignment, or determine mine, which is making this meaningless.
Quote:
aren't you the one who said yesterday 'knights is a hard read as either alignment, but I think he has been slightly villagery' or something along those lines?
cause you're literally only talking about me right now cause I voted you and its pretty transparent if tbqh.
cause you're literally only talking about me right now cause I voted you and its pretty transparent if tbqh.
03-26-2017
, 10:57 AM
03-26-2017
, 10:59 AM