Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
MtG IV Game Thread MtG IV Game Thread

06-02-2017 , 07:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by tchaz
gjge UD.

you are the broken-Tony-Parker to Gabe's Ricky Rubio. hang your head and weep.
How many ww games are going to run without old-ass Tony Parker, though?
MtG IV Game Thread Quote
06-02-2017 , 08:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by tchaz
Crikey - I'm not having this convo again I hope, esp with a goodfaith interlocutant like Kaze.

(i) you don't have to read the site through tapatalk - and increasingly many phone posters (not only in pog) don't because it is so **** - despite 2+2 seemingly having a commercial agreement to try to spam ppl to move over to tapatalk

(ii) the real point:

the wolves are - assumably - not all phone posting on tapatalk when they are trying to find peeks. they can just get on a computer - or, woah, not use tapatalk. have you ever been in a situation where this was actually a problem for the wolf-team?

villagers - can crowd-source. I've never seen a village seriously disadvantaged by some of them not being able to read thread titles. have you?
Why should I have to alter my choice of message board reading app just because you want to play ******ed games with hidden messages?

Werewolf is a game about deception in communication. It's not about structuring your communication such that you try to hide it from other players. There's absolutely no reason to allow that - i.e. it adds nothing to the game - and there are reasons to disallow it. It's a no-brainer to make it against the rules.

btw, there is a hidden message in this post. Can you see it? Is THAT allowed? If not, why not?
MtG IV Game Thread Quote
06-02-2017 , 08:53 PM
MtG IV Game Thread Quote
06-02-2017 , 10:56 PM
- woke up at 6am to kill someone
- excellent lolcats
- A+ postgame performance

sorry janny and NL, chrisv = MVP



Spoiler:
lol tchaz
MtG IV Game Thread Quote
06-03-2017 , 12:33 AM
, but I think you mean:

btw I just took a look in Tapatalk and the hidden message in the first post is visible as well, some quirk in the way it processes url tags. I'll need to remember to use [ color ] tags for all my hidden-message needs in future games. Maybe later in the arms race we can graduate to steganography.
MtG IV Game Thread Quote
06-03-2017 , 01:44 AM
Loltchaz

In a game where many players cannot see post title edits, allowing this is like allowing players to send PM's to eachother
MtG IV Game Thread Quote
06-03-2017 , 01:15 PM
Gabe is a villager
MtG IV Game Thread Quote
06-04-2017 , 12:45 PM
What if you gave people land instead of mana?

Untap your land every night. Might reduce the need for timebombs and let people cast more stuff.

Casting stuff is fun

Naturally all the cards would have to be balanced around this change, and you could still give out bonus manas in events.
MtG IV Game Thread Quote
06-04-2017 , 12:49 PM
I was gonna make a post about how WW is about determining whether people are dirty liars...rather than if they voted villagers or wolves.

And that I think it's absolutely possible separate the bussers from the villagers a >rand amount of the time...

But in a big mash you often just don't usually have time to fully re-examine everyone so the people who killed wolves usually get a pass. So I dunno really.

I would say i get bussed the same without the free incentives though and i'd be just as happy about it
MtG IV Game Thread Quote
06-04-2017 , 03:35 PM
Giving people permanent land means more info for the players and mods to track. This game is tough to mod already.
MtG IV Game Thread Quote

      
m