Now you know how I felt in FFIX...

yeah must have sucked being a wolf there amirite

but his arguments are sooooo good

soah's argument has occurred to me for the longest time. its a good one.

this reminds me of a time where vmf was a wolf in one game and I was pushing him and we had a little history but not a ton and I had read him well a few games in a row. Simultaneously in another game, I was saying he's a villager and he was getting pushed, and to defend himself, he said that I read him really well and ppl should listen. Pretty much made me push him super hard in hte other game.

lollipops.

I like multitabling though, even thought I can't really do it at the moment

I know my opinion isn't worth much around here but agree with atak about gimmicks. People who say gimmicks have an edge obviously haven't played ww under a gimmick. People inherently don't trust you because they don't know who you are, which makes it harder for you to influence the lynch and defend yourself from being lynched.

People don't trust you because it's necessary for equilibrium. It's like the lemon market.

I am not spanish. I just live there. I left for a temporal project, met some Spanish woeman and that was that.

I guess that makes sense.

I love this.

Re: the strawman fallacy: "Tis can be used with any argument as long as you're stupid enough."


You mean the standard misunderstanding of what it means? Wtf was that doing in a pleading?

Why is it unrealistic?


There's some truth to this, though I hadn't thought about that aspect of it. A variation of it is that though it might to rise to the level of "distrust" (at least no more than is inherent to werewolf, your opinions don't carry particular (one might argue undue) weight when you're on a gimmick.

I know that when I play as a gimmick it doesn't matter a lot early in the game because my style doesn't rely heavily on convincing people I know what I'm talking about early on; none of my gimmicks have gotten deep (at least not that I recall), so I don't know whether there would be a different effect if that were to happen. I don't know that this counterbalances the advantage I could have if I were hiding some aspect of my true meta, though. Maybe for some players it would actually be more a disadvantage than the corresponding advantage; in fact, I'm pretty sure it would.