Originally Posted by Sun Tzu
just because someone else told you to make them doesn't mean you didn't make them
or make them not cases
if you don't want people to say you made a case on someone, don't make a case on someone just because someone tells you to
You've been giving me sh*t for "defending" FCBL. You don't get to have it both ways and also give me sh*t for doing a reread of him early on d1 and pronouncing him a >rand wolf.
and cases are not the same thing as rereads
maybe I'm being pedantic about that
I don't care
when I reread Scootaloo (for example) at Jim's behest, I didn't frame it as "here's my case for why I have no strong read on Scootaloo" -- that would be ludicrous. It was billed as my comments on the collected works of Scootaloo up to that point, and that's exactly what it was.