Game of Thrones 2: A Clash of Kings - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (July 30th, 2012)

[Henrik Sedin]

Originally Posted by iversonian

henrik, how bout we just settle it by you answering this question. if you were to remove every one of my mechanics related posts and, from the remainder, think i'm a villager, would the addition of those mechanics posts (assuming they are good and tend to lead the village in the right direction) make more or less likely to be a villager?

well if i assume that they're good, sure, but why would i do that?

you could be a wolf lying about mechanics, or a villager/wolf who is ignorant of the mechanics. i just think it's mostly a waste of time, unless you really think you have something good/pertinent to add to the discussion. but a lot of times what you get are ppl herping & derping about the mech stuff bc they have no idea what's going on (or they're wolves who just wanna fill space and look busy). it's stupid and pointless, let's just play the game. make reads on players, lynch the wolfy ones who aren't trying to solve the game, profit.

imo

[Willi]

Originally Posted by ut2010

Willi seems a little perturbed that SE styled on him.

Ut bags also some wolf points for not having anything to say about other players and picking easy se vs pog topic. My se **** was pretty late. So he clearly has read entire thread.

[Supine]

I'm not sure wether its awesome that chips has no opinion of me despite several games, or pathetic that he doesn't remember me

[Chips Ahoy]

Originally Posted by Willi

Could couple of players would volunteer to be cliffmakers for the game?

I endorse this post.

When you make important posts like cliffs, tables of past stuff, etc., tag the post so people can find it in search. I will tag mine like so:

Originally Posted by Tag

Oreos

Everybody who makes reference posts should apply their own tag that they make up.

I put the tag inside of quotes so when somebody quotes it, the tag goes away. Thus only the originals show up in search.

[Chips Ahoy]

Originally Posted by iversonian

by what sorcery do you know this? ok, so we know who the likely SPKs are. what else?

This concept is for mid-late game. You'll have players who are "must kill" and players who are "obvious villagers". Don't waste your time on them.

[Andynan]

this gonna be good

willi is villa lock
chips pretty much as well
henrik villagery

Chipsy, add SPK targets to your scorecard?

[Supine]

Originally Posted by jonnyd

damn i was so excited to play but now people are talking about talking about mechanics... zzzz i guess i'll get some shuteye and wake up to 1000 posts to not read.

This is post #56 or so - a game this size always begins with fluff or mechanics. jonnyd knows this because he has played the HP games, one of which featured me wanging his wife. Make a read yourself if its so annoying. I hope you wake up to a wagon. jonnyd

I read henrik v iver - basically, I think iver talking mechanics d1 doesn't mean anything (ie henrik is wrong for calling him wolfy) but imo, Henriks accusation was more of the villager-trying-too-hard kind than a wolf trying to find a mislynch/look villagery. I will revisit that later if nothing else interesting pops up..

[ut2010]

Originally Posted by Willi

Ut bags also some wolf points for not having anything to say about other players and picking easy se vs pog topic. My se **** was pretty late. So he clearly has read entire thread.

Don't hate on the seer man. Henrik is a villager.

Spoiler:

Thats not my peak because i don't have one yet

[Supine]

Originally Posted by Andynan

this gonna be good

willi is villa lock
chips pretty much as well

No - check the advice they are giving. It's nothing they couldn't post as wolf. Granted its good advice, to me its not much more clearing than posting mechanics speculation.

obv you know this and just made awesome TONE READS

[Monkey Banana]

Hi everyone

Originally Posted by LuckayLuck

Anybody want to hypothesize any theories on which of the houses are villagers, which are wolves, and which are neutrals?

Can't do this without hinting at your role?

Originally Posted by CPHoya

How involved in GoT1 was Willi? Some of that list doesn't look like normal willi.

Wasn't in it. Did you elaborate? Already bored with his moralising. As though he was in any position to instruct anyone on how to behave in a werewolf game.

Pissed only to get a small x as a wolf from Chips.

Rubbish role so I will obviously be alive deep. Come at me wolves.

Henrik, if someone does mechanics posts as their meta, they're obviously going to do it in both roles so what's the point of getting into it with them?

[Monkey Banana]

Anyone feel they've posted anything worth reading or just the usual combination of fluff, thin pushes and boring stuff that you could figure out for yourself if you read the OPs?

[Henrik Sedin]

Originally Posted by Supine

...jonnyd knows this because he has played the HP games, one of which featured me wanging his wife...

hey now!

I read henrik v iver - basically, I think iver talking mechanics d1 doesn't mean anything (ie henrik is wrong for calling him wolfy)...

but i didn't call him wolfy. i said him talking mechanics all the live long day is role neutral for him (IMO), i said this in Awesomemash or whatever game he got vigged D1 when we were v/v. for some reason this read got him super BH, as he doesn't see himself as a mechtalk heavy player. i disagree, but w/e. i find it kinda weird that he's being so Jo Galloway about it, not sure what to make of that exactly.

[Supine]

dude, i just want you to make some reads. you obv have a habit of getting bogged down in mech talk as we all know. now last game when we were v/v i rightly pointed out that this is pretty role neutral for you specifically, but in general we also all know that the easiest thing in the world is for woalves to just talk mechanics all days in a mishmash where no one knows wtf is going on. so all i'm saying is be aware of it, and don't just talk mechanics all goddamn day. i know you'd love to, but make some reads lest you get blasted in the face again or something.

So you were worried that iver would be looking wolfy to the vig and catch a daykill, thats it?

[Andynan]

Originally Posted by Supine

No - check the advice they are giving. It's nothing they couldn't post as wolf. Granted its good advice, to me its not much more clearing than posting mechanics speculation.

obv you know this and just made awesome TONE READS

It's not really but Willi's long posts are pro-village, I read them and they are nice. I dont think he'd post them as a wolf.

Originally Posted by Supine

This is post #56 or so - a game this size always begins with fluff or mechanics. jonnyd knows this because he has played the HP games, one of which featured me wanging his wife. Make a read yourself if its so annoying. I hope you wake up to a wagon. jonnyd

I read henrik v iver - basically, I think iver talking mechanics d1 doesn't mean anything (ie henrik is wrong for calling him wolfy) but imo, Henriks accusation was more of the villager-trying-too-hard kind than a wolf trying to find a mislynch/look villagery. I will revisit that later if nothing else interesting pops up..

You are a villager on tone and I'll sponge you here, how can he possibly be dissapointed at mech talks, what should we be doing on page 1, discussing day 0 and night 0, consolidating wagons? reading ppl that are yet to post?

redonkolous

jonnyd

[iversonian]

henrik, if am butthurt (yellow imo), here's why. i accurately predicted the existence of the tailor/janitor in the last game. for this service to the village, i got wagoned and subsequently shot in the face d1. if i should take another early one in the face this game for making a note involving mechanics, i am going to get MAD. so yeah, now you know where i'm coming from.