Originally Posted by atakdog
I do think it's true that many people would. I know also that some people wouldn't. The latter is why some people employ that style successfully in werewolf — and that in turn is why some of us don't play werewolf with those people.
I think that the people whom you're tying to convince would listen to you more if you adopted a different style, and at the moment — to the extent you're posting in good faith — that is what matters.
I am not capable of convincing you guys of anything because I am seen as an outsider with little WW experience. Regardless of my manner, you guys would not be interested in what I have to say. Please dont pretend that this is not 100% the case. Go look at the initial responses to my OP if you are not convinced.
The only way I was going to get my ideas debated properly was to get a fair and free discussion of ideas going, something that POG was lacking before I made my thread.
Furthermore, about your ideas of what is 'un POG-like', well, you're falling into the same arrogant stance as TL did earlier. You do not get to decide on your own what is 'un POG-like'.