Originally Posted by El_Timon
First off, Crossnerd, thank you for modding.
Congratulations to the wolves and my hats off to Jim who put an inspired performance and won this game for his team. The amount of WIM you had in this game was impressive, well deserved win.
As I was reading a thread that Binkles linked me to earlier, I found this quote that perfectly summarizes what I think of this game:
The game got took over by a bunch of personal issues that clouded the village judgement. I said it when I was alive, Binkles POE list solved the game on d2. I got NKed and no one really looked into why. McAvoy had the wolf team figured out early on d4 and got lynched. Blaming Gad for not participating is dumb, you should have just lynched him.
It was really fun playing in this game, and all those issues aside I hope I can play again in such a fully stacked lineup.
Originally Posted by younguns87
When no one else puts in effort it's hard to lynch Jim there when Mets is still alive using the half way rule type deal.
From now on when Jim doesn't make sense I'm lynching him though.
Halfway rule is silly, lynch the wolfy players
Originally Posted by metsandfinsfan
yeah but i was alive too
Originally Posted by JimHalpert
just read all the postgame.
i hate when it deteriorates into this
all ill say on the matter is i hope everyone cools off at some point and remembers its just a game
A few points about the game itself:
- I was really happy to get to finish the game before YG came back because he frightens me.
- El Timon played really well, and I hope he realizes my comments during the game about "if i didnt outwork his nonsense ill quit" was just me being a wolf. I was really impressed, had planned to mislynch him, and realized I wouldn't be able to. I also think my general theory about him is actually correct, and when he DOES rand wolf for the first time he's gonna pwn
The initial game plan was for gad to win the game starting day 2. I went into "make them read my spew wrong" mode by clearing 4 people thin (binkles, annie, mcavoy, willi) and hoping that when I was lynched the focus was brought to "why else would he clear them unless he's protecting a wolf". I had also planned to not speak to/of/about El Timon period to make that look bad (aka, my plan to mislynch him) but Him and Binkles ruined that.
I thought I'd get lynched at some point because, well, the last395849 times ive been a wolf I have and I had no real confidence about it + everyone had kind of mentioned it. We were able to take out my largest detractors (Binkles, Nofear, Timon) and I was able to kind of hide behind all the work I put in.
I do think all my clears - though thin - are things I'd think as a vilalger though. Just maybe not lock status.
Regarding the mcavoy lynch: I think people need to remember that they don't read everyone well, but they read some people very well. Aksdal is just locked into mcavoys mind, and I truthfully believe people should believe him until he shows us a reason not to. I feel the same about other combinations (VMF and Cross to each other, Noah to Evene, just as a couple off the top of my head). It sounds dumb, but I do believe it.
I hope everyone at some point comes back and says they had fun.
I'd run it back with this 13 any day of the week <3
Thx for the mod and good theme cross <3
Yeah thanks Cross, you did really well and the roles/pictures were a+
Originally Posted by Aksdal
Mac was actually playing pretty well from the short bit I railed after I died.
Binkles is learning to read him like I do. If we both say he's a villager and both die, then just don't lunch him
Originally Posted by Aksdal
You didn't get lynched though
You were playing well
But not lynching gad over mets after that level of effort and post count seems bad at f5
Consider this. If a wolf has a win at f5 set up, they'll do what they can to not change anything so if a villager is getting lynched tey just let it happen. If a villager is at f5, they do what they can if they're getting lynched or not because just themself staying alive isn't enough. They have to make sure they don't lunch one of the other villagers.
Gad not participating there really should out himself
I think the biggest thing was Mets randomly voting an afk a few hours into day.
Being results oriented yes it was the right move. But as a villager you always have to consider how you're perceived. In fact I brought this up on page 2.
Mets voting an afk 10 minutes after Jim said 'nobody be retarded and vote before I come back' is awful. It gives Jim something to focus on about why Mets is a wolf, it means the rest of the villagers don't have to clear themselves anymore, and Gad was obviously the 'easiest' mislynch.